16. MANOTICK MILL
QUARTER - THE PROPOSED ACQUISITION OF LAND QUARTIER DU MOULIN DE MANOTICK - L'ACQUISTION DE TERRAIN PROPOSE |
Committee Recommendations
That Council:
1. Approve the
establishment of a Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation (holding company), as
described in this report, in accordance with the Business Case Study set out in
Document 1 attached hereto;
2. Approve the
acquisition in fee simple of two (2) parcels of land consisting of a combined
land area of approximately 4056 sq. m. owned by the Rideau Valley Conservation
Authority (RVCA) and known as the Dickinson House, the Carriage House and
Weaver’s House being Parcel “A” and the Ayer’s Building being Parcel “B”, as
shown on the Annex “A” sketch attached to this report, for the consideration of
$1,400,000 plus GST subject to final adjustments on closing and the following
condition. The RVCA would be required to enter into a heritage easement
agreement with the City for the Watson’s Mill property, being Parcel “C”, as
shown on the Annex “A” sketch attached to this report, and to agree to transfer
the Watson’s Mill property to Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. for $1 subject to the
City being provided with an option to purchase this property for $1 if Watson’s
Mill Manotick Inc. at any time offers the Mill property for lease or sale;
3. Approve the
acquisition in fee simple of a 2144 sq. m. parcel of land, owned by the Estate
of Anna Dorothy Clapp, described as Part of Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front,
North Gower; Part Lot 1 N/S Bridge Street, Plan 15 As In NG13177; City of
Ottawa (PIN: 03903-1114) and being Parcel “D” as shown on the Annex “A” sketch
attached to this report, for the consideration of $590,000 plus GST subject to
final adjustments on closing;
4. Approve the
acquisition in fee simple of a 1648 sq. m. parcel of land, owned by Maurice
Holloway, described as Part of Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower,
As In NG10893; City of Ottawa (PIN: 03903-1158) and being Parcel “E” as shown
on the Annex “A” sketch attached to this report, for the consideration of
$250,000 plus GST subject to final adjustments on closing;
5. Approve the transfer
of the properties, shown as Parcels “A”, “B”, “D” & “E” on the Annex “A”
sketch attached to this report to the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation subject
to the repayment and heritage and easement conditions and the public use
covenants set out more particularly in Document 2 of this report;
6. Direct staff to
continue to pursue with Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc., Energy Ottawa and Parks Canada,
the potential for and economic viability of generating electrical power at
Watson’s Mill; and
7. Approve a grant to Dickinson Heritage Management Inc. (DSHMI) in an amount not to exceed $25,000 to be used to offset the actual costs incurred by DSHMI in the preparation of its business plan as described in this report.
Recommandations du comité
Que le
Conseil:
1. Approuve l’établissement de la Société
du quartier du moulin de Manotick (une société de portefeuille), selon la
description dans le présent rapport, ainsi que l’étude de rentabilisation
figurant au document 1 annexé aux présentes;
2. Approuve l’acquisition en fief simple
de deux (2) parcelles de terrain consistant en une superficie de terre combinée
d’environ 4056 mètres carrés appartenant à l’Office de protection de la
nature de la vallée de Rideau (OPNVR) et connues sous l’appellation de
Dickinson House, Carriage House et Weaver’s House, constituant la
parcelle « A », et Ayer’s Building, constituant la
parcelle « B », comme il est illustré dans le croquis de
l’annexe « A » annexée au présent rapport, pour la somme de
1 400 000 $ plus la TPS sous réserve des rajustements finals au
moment de la signature du contrat et au condition suivant. L’OPNVR conclue une
entente de servitude du patrimoine avec la Ville pour le bien immeuble de la
Meunerie Watson, constituant la parcelle « C » ainsi qu’il est
illustré dans le croquis de l’annexe « A » annexée au présent
rapport, et consentira à céder le dit bien immeuble à Watson’s Mill Manotick
Inc. pour le montant de 1 $ sous réserve que la Ville bénéficie de
l’option d’acquérir le dit bien immeuble pour le montant de 1 $ si
Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. met en location ou en vente un moment donné le bien
immeuble;
3. Approuve l’acquisition en fief simple
d’une parcelle de terrain de 2 144 mètres carrés appartenant à la
succession de Anna Dorothy Clapp, décrite en tant que partie du Lot 1,
Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower; partie du Lot 1 N/S rue
Bridge, Plan 15 comme dans NG13177; Ville d’Ottawa (PIN : 03903-1114)
et constituant la parcelle « D », comme il est illustré dans le
croquis de l’annexe « A » annexée au présent rapport, pour la
somme de 590 000 $ plus la TPS sous réserve des rajustements finals
au moment de la signature du contrat;
4. Approuve l’acquisition en fief simple
d’une parcelle de terrain de 1 648 mètres carrés appartenant à
Maurice Holloway, décrite comme la partie du Lot 1, Concession A,
Broken Front, North Gower, comme dans NG10893; Ville d’Ottawa (PIN :
03903-1158) et constituant la parcelle « E », comme il est
illustré dans le croquis de l’annexe « A » annexée au présent rapport, pour la somme de
250 000 $ plus la TPS sous réserve des rajustements finals au moment
de la signature du contrat;
5. Approuve la cession de ces biens
immeubles, constituant les parcelles « A », « B »,
« D », et « E », comme il est illustré dans le croquis de
l’annexe « A » annexée au présent rapport, à la Société du
quartier du moulin de Manotick, selon les conditions figurant au
document 2 annexé aux présentes;
6. Demande au personnel de continuer à
examiner, avec Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc., Énergie Ottawa et Parcs Canada, la
possibilité de production d’énergie électrique à la Meunerie Watson ou sa
viabilité économique; et
7. Approuve une subvention à Dickinson
Square Management Inc. (DSHMI) d’un montant ne devant pas dépasser
25 000 $ et devant servir à payer les coûts effectifs pour DSHMI de
la préparation de son plan d’activités ainsi qu’il est décrit dans le présent
rapport.
DOCUMENTATION
1. Executive Director's (Business Transformation
Services) and Deputy City Manager's (Community and Protective Services) joint
report dated 8 November 2007 (ACS2007-BTS-RPM-0045).
2. Extract of Draft Minute, 19 November 2007.
Report to/Rapport au :
Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee
Comité des services organisationnels et du développement économique
and Council / et au Conseil
8 November 2007 / le 8 novembre 2007
Submitted by/Soumis par : Stephen A. Finnamore, Executive Director,
Business Transformation Services / Directeur exécutif, Services de
transformation des activités
and/et
Steve Kanellakos, Deputy City Manager/Directeur municipal adjoint,
Community and Protective Services/Services communautaires et de
protection
Contact
Person/Personne ressource : Gordon MacNair, Manager Real Estate Services
Real
Property Asset Management/Gestion des actifs des biens immobiliers
(613)
580-2424 x 21217, Gordon.MacNair@ottawa.ca
and/et
Colleen Hendrick, Director
Cultural Services and Community Funding/ Services culturels et
financement communautaire
(613) 580-2424 x 24366, colleen hendrick@ottawa.ca
ACS2007-BTS-RPM-0045 |
SUBJECT: |
THE PROPOSED ACQUISITION OF LAND |
OBJET : |
QUARTIER DU MOULIN DE MANOTICK - L’Acquistion De
TERRAIN PROPOSE |
That the Corporate Services
and Economic Development Committee consider recommending that Council:
1.
Approve the establishment of a Manotick Mill
Quarter Corporation (holding company), as described in this report, in
accordance with the Business Case Study set out in Document 1 attached hereto;
3. Approve the acquisition in fee simple of a 2144 sq. m. parcel of land, owned by the Estate of Anna Dorothy Clapp, described as Part of Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower; Part Lot 1 N/S Bridge Street, Plan 15 As In NG13177; City of Ottawa (PIN: 03903-1114) and being Parcel “D” as shown on the Annex “A” sketch attached to this report, for the consideration of $590,000 plus GST subject to final adjustments on closing;
4. Approve the acquisition in fee simple of a 1648 sq. m. parcel of land, owned by Maurice Holloway, described as Part of Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower, As In NG10893; City of Ottawa (PIN: 03903-1158) and being Parcel “E” as shown on the Annex “A” sketch attached to this report, for the consideration of $250,000 plus GST subject to final adjustments on closing;
5. Approve the transfer of the properties, shown as Parcels “A”, “B”, “D” & “E” on the Annex “A” sketch attached to this report to the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation subject to the repayment and heritage and easement conditions and the public use covenants set out more particularly in Document 2 of this report;
6. Direct staff to continue to pursue with Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc., Energy Ottawa and Parks Canada, the potential for and economic viability of generating electrical power at Watson’s Mill; and
7. Approve a grant to Dickinson Heritage Management Inc. (DSHMI) in an amount not to exceed $25,000 to be used to offset the actual costs incurred by DSHMI in the preparation of its business plan as described in this report.
Que le Comité des services organisationnels et du développement économique considérer à recommander au Conseil ce qui suit:
1. Approuver l’établissement de la Société du quartier du moulin de
Manotick (une société de portefeuille), selon la description dans le présent
rapport, ainsi que l’étude de rentabilisation figurant au document 1
annexé aux présentes;
3.
Approuver
l’acquisition en fief simple d’une parcelle de terrain de
2 144 mètres carrés appartenant à la succession de Anna Dorothy
Clapp, décrite en tant que partie du Lot 1, Concession A, Broken
Front, North Gower; partie du Lot 1 N/S rue Bridge, Plan 15 comme
dans NG13177; Ville d’Ottawa (PIN : 03903-1114) et constituant la parcelle
« D », comme il est illustré dans le croquis de l’annexe « A »
annexée au présent
rapport, pour la somme de 590 000 $ plus la TPS sous réserve des
rajustements finals au moment de la signature du contrat;
4.
Approuver
l’acquisition en fief simple d’une parcelle de terrain de
1 648 mètres carrés appartenant à Maurice Holloway, décrite comme la
partie du Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower, comme dans
NG10893; Ville d’Ottawa (PIN : 03903-1158) et constituant la
parcelle « E », comme il est illustré dans le croquis de
l’annexe « A » annexée
au présent rapport, pour la somme de 250 000 $ plus la TPS sous
réserve des rajustements finals au moment de la signature du contrat;
5. Approuver la cession de ces biens immeubles, constituant les parcelles « A », « B »,
« D », et « E », comme il est illustré dans le croquis de
l’annexe « A » annexée au présent rapport, à la Société du quartier du moulin de Manotick, selon les conditions figurant au document 2 annexé aux présentes;
6.
Demander
au personnel de continuer à examiner, avec Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc., Énergie
Ottawa et Parcs Canada, la possibilité de production d’énergie électrique à la
Meunerie Watson ou sa viabilité économique; et
7.
Approuver
une subvention à Dickinson Square Management Inc. (DSHMI) d’un montant ne
devant pas dépasser 25 000 $ et devant servir à payer les coûts
effectifs pour DSHMI de la préparation de son plan d’activités ainsi qu’il est
décrit dans le présent rapport.
BACKGROUND
The RVCA is now completing the construction of
a new headquarters facility in Beryl Gaffney Park, under the provisions of a
ground lease and construction/building lease agreements with the City, and will
be vacating its Dickinson Square properties by early 2008.
Since the RVCA’s business plan for its new
headquarters project includes a provision for the sale of its Dickinson Square
properties, the RVCA undertook a “Best Use” study, carried out in 2006 by Commonwealth Historic Management Ltd.,
which clearly indicated the
community preference that these significant buildings in the historic part of
the Village of Manotick remain in public ownership.
On 11 July 2006, when City Council approved the
terms and conditions for the agreements between the City and the RVCA to provide
for the construction of a new RVCA headquarters building in Beryl Gaffney Park,
Council also approved a condition that
the RVCA provide at
nominal consideration to the City of Ottawa an "Option to Purchase"
the Dickinson Square properties at fair market value for a period up to a
maximum of 18 months.
Council then directed staff to enter into
discussions with the RVCA, Dickinson Square Heritage Management Inc. (DSHMI),
and the broader community in order to develop options that provide for the property
to remain under public ownership and to report back to Committee and Council at
least 6 months prior to the expiration of the option period.
The resulting Option Agreement was executed on 23 November 2006 and the Option Period will terminate on 23 May 2008 unless otherwise extended by mutual agreement. As a result, City staff has undertaken due diligence work (real estate appraisal, building condition audit, internal circulation) and consulted with the RVCA and DSHMI representatives in order to be able to report back to Council by the end of November 2007.
During the property appraisal process, RESD staff noted that the RVCA has a license, at nominal cost, from Parks Canada for the rights to excess water spilled in west channel to allow the Watson’s Mill turbines to operate and that this may provide an opportunity to generate electrical power at the Mill.
City staff also
noted, as part of the due diligence work, that:
§ The property at 1135 Mill Street, between the Weavers House at 1131 Mill Street and the City owned the property at 1137 Mill Street (leased to the Millers Oven), was listed for sale at $339K and reportedly conditionally sold;
§ The property owned by the Estate of Dorothy Clapp at 1125 Clapp Lane, which property also abuts Bridge Street and Mill Street as a key entryway to Dickinson Square, was listed for sale at $699K;
§ The property owned by Maurice Holloway at the corner of Bridge Street & Mill Street across, which is directly across Mill Street from the Clapp property and abuts the west channel of the Rideau River, has reportedly been offered to the RVCA for $300K; and
§ The Manotick Village Plan, as set out in Volume 2c of the City’s Official Plan adopted under By-law 203-2003 City’s Official Plan , limits the proposed institutional uses and offices uses in the Historic Village East Sector to those under the existing zoning and provides for Council to examine the feasibility of relocating the RVCA offices and establishing a “Mill Quarter” based on commercial tourist/heritage type uses (accommodation, boutiques, galleries, craft and other specialty outlets, museums, restaurants and studios). Document 5 of this report provides further information on the Village Plan for Manotick.
Document 3 of this report provides detailed Background Information regarding the RVCA’s need to sell the Dickinson Square properties and the due diligence work undertaken by City staff in 2007.
In 2007, DSHMI commissioned
Canadian Cultural Resource Consultants Inc. (London, ON) in partnership with
Goldsmith Borgal & Company, Architects Ltd (Toronto, ON) to prepare a
concept plan/business plan to support a proposed option by DSHMI for the City
to acquire the RVCA’s Dickinson
Square Properties and for DSHMI to operate and manage these building and
Dickinson Square as a heritage cultural centre to provide opportunities and
space for arts, heritage programming and community activities.
On 16 October 2007, DSHMI received the initial draft of the Business Plan from the consultant and forwarded a copy to the City on condition that the plan is considered a work-in-progress since DSHMI Board would also be reviewing the initial draft that same evening.
Following the DSHMI Board review of the initial draft of the Plan and the public meeting, DSHMI had the draft revised and, on 23 October 2007, submitted a second draft of its Business Plan to the City again on condition that the plan is considered a work-in-progress.
On 17 October 2007, staff from the City’s
Cultural Services & Community Funding Branch, Parks & Recreation
Branch, Economic & Environmental Sustainability Branch, Rural Affairs
Office, and Real Property Asset Management Branch met with the Deputy City
Manger of Community and Protective Services Department to set a direction for
reporting back to Council by the end of November 2007 regarding options that provide for the RVCA’s Dickinson
Square properties to
remain under public ownership given the information in the initial draft of DSHMI’s Business Plan
and the information from the City’s due diligence work.
At the meeting, staff agreed that a report should be prepared for consideration in November 2007, by the Agricultural and Rural Affairs Committee, the Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee and Council which outlines and evaluates DSHMI’s draft Business Plan and any other potential City option for the City acquiring the RVCA’s Dickinson Square properties on the basis of objectives as follows:
Representatives from the City’s Rural Affairs Office, the Cultural Services and Community Funding Branch, and Real Estate Services Division then attended the October 18th pubic meeting organized by DSHMI and subsequently reviewed the second draft of DSHMI’s Business Plan that was submitted on 23 October 2007.
After reviewing DSHMI’s draft Business Plan, revised as of 23 October
2007, City staff is supportive of the major objectives of the draft Plan and
acknowledges that it fully addresses objectives #’s 1 & 2 outlined above.
However the draft Plan only partially addresses objectives #’s 3, 4 & 5
outlined above and does not meet objective #6 from the City’s financial
perspective.
With respect to objective #3, DSHMI’s darft Plan is clearly more than adequate in providing heritage and cultural opportunities for the Mill Quarter, as envisioned by the Village Plan set out in the City’s Official Plan for Manotick, but it does not provide for any significant commercial tourist/heritage type uses (accommodations, boutiques, galleries, crafts and other specialty outlets, museums, restaurants and studios) as detailed in the Village Plan.
With respect
to objective #4, DSHMI’s draft Plan provides for the preservation of Dickinson Square as a
public open space with enhanced
opportunities for heritage and cultural events but the square is not formally
defined in relation to that space which would be exclusive to the users of the
adjacent buildings.
With respect to objective #5, DSHMI’s draft
Plan provides only for the City to own/control and limit development of the
RVCA’s properties and does not provide for development opportunities and
controls for private sector use of these properties and the other privately
owned properties in the Mill Quarter that are needed to meet objective # 3 outlined
above.
With respect to objective #6, DSHMI’s draft
Plan assumes that the City will cover the property acquisition, life cycle
costs, and building retrofit cost for building code and other regulatory
compliance with respect to the changes of use contemplated by the draft
Plan. The present value cost to the
City for these items exceeds $3M.
As a result, City staff does not feel that
the City should acquire the RVCA properties on the basis of the option
presented in DSHMI’s draft Business Plan.
However, staff also acknowledges that there
will be even less opportunity for the City to achieve its objectives for the
Mill Quarter as outlined above if the City does not exercise the option to
acquire the RVCA’s and adjacent properties that are being offered for sale by
the respective owners.
Based on the objectives set out for the Mill Quarter as outlined above,
and the current opportunity for the City
to purchase the RVCA, Clapp and Holloway properties which abut Dickinson
Square properties at current market value, staff believe that the City should
establish a Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation as outlined in Recommendation #1
of this report. The proposed corporation would be established so that it is
ultimately financially self-sustaining, as outlined in Documents #’s 1 & 2
and in the Disposition Section of this report, to provide Council with a tool
to fully control the development and use of the properties shown as Parcels “A”
to “E” on Annex “A” of this report and achieve the City’s objectives for the
Mill Quarter.
After discussions with RVCA staff, RESD staff believe that the RVCA would
likely agree to selling to the City the Dickinson House, the Carriage Shed, the
Ayer’s Building and the Weaver’s House properties for $1.4M and to transfer the
Watson’s Mill property to Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. for $1, subject to the
City being provided with an option to purchase this property for $1 if Watson’s
Mill Manotick Inc. at any time offers the Mill property for lease or sale. It
also appears that the RVCA would likely agree to enter into a heritage easement
agreement with the City for the Mill property prior to transferring it to
Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. The $1.4M purchase price for the proposed
transaction between the City and the RVCA is consistent with the appraised
value of the properties as established by independent appraisal reports.
If City does not buy RVCA properties, there is no guarantee that the properties will be sold in the near future and, in that event, the RVCA will then have to increase its levy to offset the carrying costs for the $1.4M with the City paying approx. 91% of this levy
Once the levy is increased there
is also no guarantee that the RVCA will eliminate the additional levy when the
properties are sold as it might decide to use the sales revenue for other
projects. It is noted that while the City pays 91% of levy it has only 6
members on the 12 member RVCA Board with only three of the members being City
of Ottawa Councillors.
The Agricultural and Rural Affairs Committee, at its
meeting on 8 November 2008, provided direction to staff that, if the City
purchases the RVCA’s Dickinson Square properties, the RVCA should be required
to pay down the amount borrowed from the City (lease/debenture)
for its new headquarters building by $600K as provided for in the RVCA’s
Business Case for its new building described in Document 3 of this report. The Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee may wish
to recommend to Council that this be an additional condition, to those already
set out in Recommendation 2 of this report, for purchasing the RVCA’s Dickinson
Square properties.
After the meeting on 17 October 2007, RESD staff initiated real estate
appraisals for the Clapp and Holloway properties set out as Parcels “D” &
“E” on Annex “A” attached to this report and negotiated Agreements of Purchase
and Sales for these properties which agreements are conditional on Council
approval. The purchase prices for these properties as set out in
Recommendations #’s 3 & 4 of this report are consistent with the currently
appraised market values and are substantially less than the original asking
prices.
The acquisition of the Clapp and Holloway properties, in addition to the
RVCA’s properties will significantly improve the opportunities for the City to
reposition the properties around the Mill Square from both planning and real
estate market perspectives and to add value.
The total cost for acquiring the
properties, as set out in Recommendations #’s 2, 3, & 4 of this report, is
$2.25M plus GST. The costs for holding these properties over a two year period,
assuming a worst case scenario that the properties will remain fully vacant, is
estimated to be $200K based on the minimum amount of operating, maintenance and
capital renewal expenditures ($100K) required to protect these assets and the
anticipated amount of expenditures ($100K) to reposition the properties from
both a planning and real estate market perspective. The total cost for acquiring and holding these properties is
estimated to be $2.45M plus GST.
With the assembly of these properties, the designation of the Rideau
Canal as a World Heritage site and the imminent provision of municipal sanitary
sewer services for this area in addition to existing municipal water services,
the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation will have a significant market
opportunity to fully recover the $2.45M in acquisition and holding costs
outlined above.
The Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation also provides the opportunity to
involve both Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. and DSHMI in the planning, development
and management of the Mill Quarter as described in the Disposition Section of
this report.
The City will not directly benefit financially from
a project to generate electrical power at Watson’s Mill if Watson’s Mill Inc.,
Energy Ottawa and Parks Canada determine that this is economically viable.
However, it is still in the best interests of the City to facilitate the
feasibility study, as set out in Recommendation # 6 of this report, to help
Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. establish additional funding sources for operating
and maintaining the Mill and its programs and for Energy Ottawa to move further
forward with its mandate to undertake environmentally and financially
sustainable projects.
At the public meeting on 18 October 2007, DSHMI indicated the need to
raise funds to cover the cost of preparing its draft Business Plan as outlined
in Document #3 of this report. Given the value of the work carried out by DSHMI
to the City in pursuing options for public control of the RVCA properties as
directed by Council on 11 July 2006, staff recommends that the City provide a
grant in an amount up to $25,000 plus GST to reimburse DSHMI for its actual
costs incurred in preparing the draft Business Plan.
Upon
approval of this report by Council, RESD will contact the Environmental
Sustainability Division of Planning, Transit and the Environment Department to
identify any
significant natural features that the Mill Corporation will be required to
address as a development corporation when making applications to the City for
development approvals.
RESD will
initiate Phase I Environmental Site Assessments as part of the due diligence
process for acquiring the properties and such other further assessments as may
be indicated by the Phase I ESA
process.
CONSULTATION
The RVCA, DSHMI, Watson’s Mill Inc. and Ward
Councillor have been consulted during the due diligence process. Staff met with DSHMI representatives and the
Ward Councillor on 7 November 2007 to provide staff feedback on the DHMI’s
draft Business Plan and to present the City's proposed strategy for a Mill
quarter Corporation to ensure that the DSHMI heritage vision could be achieved
in an alternate manner while at the same time addressing the operating and
capital financial implications for the City.
On 8 November 2007,
staff sought direction, at a in-camera session, from the Agricultural and Rural
Affairs Committee regarding the potential acquisitions of the RVCA, Clapp and
Holloway properties.
HOUSING FIRST POLICY
The recommendations of this report relate to
the implementation of the Manotick Village Plan of the Official Plan which
provides for establishment of a “Mill Quarter” based on commercial
tourist/heritage type uses (accommodation, boutiques, galleries, craft and
other specialty outlets, museums, restaurants and studios).
FINANCIAL
IMPLICATIONS
Funding for the acquisition of the properties as set out in the recommendations of this report was not included in the capital envelope of strategic initiatives.
Subject to City Council approval of this report, the
project for the property acquisitions will be included in the 2008 budget
deliberations as requiring funding.
The establishment
of the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation is based on the requirement in
Business Case Study, attached as Document 1 of this report, that the
Corporation will be financially self-sustaining with the projected expenditures
by the City totalling $2,440,000 being offset by revenues totalling $2,440,000
from repayments by the Mill Quarter Corporation, as it sells/leases portions of
the property, within two years of the properties being transferred by the City
to the Mill Corporation.
If CSEDC
recommends and Council approves an additional condition that the RVCA be
required to pay down the amount borrowed from the City (lease/debenture) for its new
headquarters building by $600K
as part of completing the property transaction with the RVCA, the City will be
credited with an amount of $600,000 as part of the statement of adjustments to
be applied to the purchase and sales transaction with the RVCA for its
Dickinson Square properties.
The grant valued at $25,000 plus GST will be funded
from Cultural Services capital project 903476 - Relocation of Cultural Space.
SUPPORTING
DOCUMENTATION
Attached are Documents #’s 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5;
Annex “A” Plan, which provide details regarding the recommendations and
information set out in this report.
DISPOSITION
Following Council’s approval
of Recommendations # 1 of this report, RESD and the Legal Services Branch, which was
consulted during the preparation of this Report, will take actions as
required to incorporate the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation described in this
report.
Following Council’s approval of Recommendation # 2
of this report and a further approval by Council in December 2007 to
provide funds for the transaction as part of the 2008 Budget, RESD, in
consultation with the Planning and Legal Services Branch and Watson’s Mill
Manotick Inc., will negotiate and complete an Agreement of Purchase and Sale
with the RVCA that includes conditions for a heritage easement agreement for
the Watson’s Mill property and for a property transfer agreement between
the RVCA, Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc and the City; and then close these
property transactions. If CSEDC recommends, and Council approves, an additional
condition that the RVCA be required to pay down
the amount borrowed from the City (lease/debenture) for its new headquarters
building by $600K as part of completing the property transaction with the RVCA, this
condition will also form part of the Agreement of Purchase and Sale.
Following Council approval of Recommendations # 3
& #4 of this report and a further approval by Council in December
2007 to provide funds for the transactions as part of the 2008 Budget, RESD
and the Legal Services Branch will complete the purchase transactions for the
Clapp & Holloway properties.
Following incorporation of the Manotick Mill Quarter
Corporation and the acquisition of the RVCA, Clapp, and Holloway properties by
the City, RESD and legal Services will arrange for the transfer of the
properties from the City to the Corporation as provided for in Recommendation
#5 of this report.
Once the properties have been transferred by the
City to the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation, RESD on behalf of the
Corporation, in consultation with the Planning and Legal Services Branch,
Watson’s Mill Inc and DSHMI, will initiate the necessary actions to place
heritage easements on the former RVCA properties, to create Dickinson Square as
a formal public open space as set out in Document 2 of this report, and to
establish appropriate development and use criteria/covenants for development of
properties within the Mill Quarter Area.
Upon establishment of the heritage easements, the
creation of a formal Dickinson Square and development and use
criteria/covenants for development of properties within the Mill Quarter Area,
RESD and the Supply Division will initiate a Request for Offers to Purchase
process for the sale or long-term leasing of the Manotick Mill Quarter
Corporation’s properties except for lands associated with the Dickinson Square.
Following approval of Recommendation #6 RESD staff
will liaise with Energy Ottawa, Parks Canada and Watson’s Mill Inc. to
facilitate the feasibility study for generating electrical power at Watson’s
Mill.
Following approval of Recommendation #7, the Cultural Services and Community Funding Branch will arrange for DSHMI to be paid for its actual expenditures, incurred until to 28 November 2007, up to an amount of $25K plus GST.
ANNEX A
DOCUMENT 1
MANOTICK MILL QUARTER CORPORATION
BUSINESS CASE STUDY
1. CORPORATE PURPOSES
The Manotick Mill Quarter
Corporation is to be incorporated for the following purposes:
·
Formalize and maintain Dickinson Square as an open space, primarily for
public use, to reflect the heritage character of the Mill Quarter and provide
enhanced opportunities for heritage and cultural events;
·
Plan, subdivide, and develop/redevelop
properties within the “Mill Quarter” area in the Village of Manotick, as
required to ensure the preservation and enhancement of the heritage buildings
and character of the “Mill Quarter” according to the provisions set out in the
Village of Manotick Plan included in Volume 2C of the City’s Official Plan, for
a heritage cultural centre with opportunities for arts and heritage programming
and community activities and for commercial accommodation,
boutiques, galleries, craft and other specialty outlets, museums, restaurants,
and studios;
·
Acquire and hold land within, and adjacent
to, the “Mill Quarter” area;
·
Clear, grade, service,
or otherwise prepare the Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation sites;
·
Improve, beautify and maintain City-owned
land, buildings and structures, within the “Mill Quarter” area beyond the
standard provided at the expense of the City generally and promote community
improvement for the Mill Quarter and adjacent areas;
·
Sell, lease or otherwise dispose or encumber
all or part of the Corporations sites;
·
Enter into Municipal
Capital Facility Agreements;
·
Enter into agreements for planning and
implementing the Corporations projects; and
·
Construct, operate, maintain and own,
including ownership of the land related thereto, one or more of the following
facilities:
(i)
Recreation, tourism and cultural facilities,
(ii) General parking facilities, and
(iii) Public transportation facilities
B. CORPORATE STRUCTURE & ORGANIZATIONAL
DIRECTION
(a) the usefulness and continued provision by the City of financial or other assistance to the corporation, and
(b) the possible winding-up of the
corporation
DOCUMENT 2
CONDITIONS FOR TRANSFER OF PROPERTIES
from
CITY of OTTAWA
to
MANOTICK MILL QUARTER CORPORATION
2.
The Manotick
Mill Quarter Corporation shall enter into heritage easement agreements with the
City for the Dickinson House, the Carriage House, Weaver’s House and Ayer’s
Building properties prior to the lease or sale of these properties; and
3. The Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation shall
formalize and maintain Dickinson Square as an open space, primarily for public
use, to reflect the heritage character of the Mill Quarter and provide enhanced
opportunities for heritage and cultural events in consultation with Dickinson Square Heritage Management Inc.
(DSHMI) and Watson’s Mill Inc.
DOCUMENT 3
MANOTICK MILL
QUARTER
RVCA DICKINSON SQUARE PROPERTIES
BACKGROUND
The RVCA is now completing the construction of
a new headquarters facility in Beryl Gaffney Park, under the provisions of a
ground lease and construction/building lease agreements with the City, and will
be vacating its Dickinson Square properties by early 2008.
The RVCA Headquarters Construction Agreement sets out funding sources as follows:
City of Ottawa Funding (Debenture/Lease payments by RVCA) $5,600,000
Waive or Grant Back of Various Permits and Fees $220,000
Tax Exemption Credit (estimate of GST and PST recovery) $600,000
RVCA Capital Reserve
and Working Fund Reserve $300,000
RVCA / RBC Line of
Credit $500,000
RVCA Revenue from Sale of Land at Chapman Mills $266,000
Total
Project Funding Available $7,486,000
Notwithstanding
the provisions of the Construction Agreement, it is understood that the RVCA’s business plan for its new
headquarters project includes a provision for the sale of its Dickinson Square
properties for at least $1.4M in order to allow the debenture for new building to be
reduced by $600K from $5.6M to $5M and to preclude the need to use $300K of
reserves and borrow $500K from its line of credit as indicated above. If it
does not sell these properties soon after the completion of its new
headquarters building, the RVCA will need to increase its levy above that
currently set out in its annual operating budget to include for additional
carrying costs related to the $1.4M. The City of Ottawa currently pays
approximately 91% of the RVCA’s annual operating levy.
Prior to offering these buildings for sale, the
RVCA undertook in 2006 a “Best Use” study, carried out by Commonwealth Historic Management Ltd.,
which clearly indicated the
community preference for these significant buildings, which are an integral
part of the Manotick Community to remain in public ownership.
As a result, on 11 July 2006 when City Council
approved the terms and conditions for the agreements between the City and the RVCA
to provide for the construction of a new RVCA headquarters building in Beryl
Gaffney Park, Council also approved a condition that the RVCA provide
at nominal consideration to the City of Ottawa an "Option to
Purchase" the Dickinson Square properties at fair market value for a
period up to a maximum of 18 months.
Council also directed staff to enter into
discussions with the RVCA, Dickinson Square Heritage Management Inc. (DSHMI),
and the broader community in order to develop options that provide for the
property to remain under public ownership and to report back to Committee and
Council at least 6 months prior to the expiration of the option period. The resulting Option
Agreement was executed on 23 November 2006 and the Option Period will terminate
on 23 May 2008 unless otherwise extended by mutual agreement. As a result, City
staff has undertaken due diligence work (real estate appraisal, building
condition audit, internal circulation) and consulted with the RVCA and DSHMI
representatives in order to be able to report back to Council by the end of
November 2007.
Following the DSHMI Board review of the initial draft of the Plan and the public meeting, DSHMI had the draft revised and, on 23 October 2007, submitted a second draft of its Business Plan to the City again on condition that the plan is considered a work-in-progress.
In early 2007, the City’s Comprehensive Asset Management Division (CAM) commissioned the firm of Temprano, Young and Ward Architects to undertake a building condition audit for the RVCA’s Dickinson Square properties using CAM’s standard terms of reference for the audit of properties having notable heritage characteristics or historical significance.
These properties were subjected to a
non-intrusive examination of the principal building systems including interior
and exterior architectural elements, mechanical and electrical systems and
structural components.
The RVCA properties were found to be in fair to good condition and have been subject to a reasonable program of remediation and refit in the past.
Based on the building condition audit report, CAM has identified the cost for the capital remediation of the subject RVCA buildings over a fifteen year period to be $1.04M or roughly 70% of the current annual budget allocated for life-cycle renewal of the comprehensive heritage portfolio owned and operated by the City ($1.5M). If the costs are equalized on an annual basis over that term, the capital reinvestment requirements for the RVCA facilities would equate to 5% of the available heritage life-cycle budget currently available to RPAM. As a consequence any acquisition plan would need to consider not only the nominal operating costs for the subject properties, which it is presumed the RVCA could provide, but should reflect a nominal 5% increase ($75K/year) to the RPAM Heritage Life-Cycle capital program commencing in the year of acquisition.
In August 2007, the Real Estate Services Division (RESD) commissioned an independent real estate appraisal to establish the current market value of the RVCA’s Dickinson Square properties. The City’s appraisal report was received in September 2007. The RVCA also allowed RESD staff to review the independent real estate appraisal reports received by the RVCA for the Dickinson House, the Carriage Shed, the Ayer’s Building and the Weaver’s House properties. An appraisal report for Watson’s Mill could not be made available for review by RESD staff as the RVCA Board of Directors had not yet officially received the appraisal report for that property.
RESD then determined from a comparison of the two independent appraisals that the total current market value of the Dickinson House, the Carriage Shed, the Ayer’s Building and the Weaver’s House properties is consistent with that established by the RVCA’s real estate appraisal. The City’s independent real estate appraisal also indicates that the value of Watson’s Mill as a stand alone property is nominal given the perceived difficulty, and unlikely possibility in the near future, of changing the use from its current use an operating museum.
RESD also initiated an internal circulation of all City Branches, Agencies and Advisory Committees in August 2007 to identify any programming requirements the City currently has in place that could be located in any of the RVCA’s Dickinson Square properties and a source of funding for those programs.
As a result of the circulation process, Police Services indicated a potential program use. If the City acquires these buildings, Police Services might consider a relocation of the Community Police Station from its current location in leased premises at 1131 Clapp Lane (lease expires 31 October 2011 with right to vacate after Oct. 31, 2008 on 6 months notice). Police Services have indicated that the RVCA buildings would need significant improvements related to, at least, handicapped access, air conditioning, and changes to corridor widths to accommodate the Community Police Station use.
The Rideau Seniors Centre have been trying, for a couple of years, to find another location in Manotick and expressed interest in leasing/using space in the Ayer’s Building and have identified this as part of their Community Funding Financial submission to the City. This potential use of the Ayer’s Building has also been included as a revenue opportunity in DSHMI’s draft Business Plan.
During the property appraisal process, RESD staff noted that the RVCA has a license, at nominal cost, from Parks Canada for the rights to excess water spilled in west channel to allow Mill turbines to operate and that Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. has restored and operates 3 of the original 6 water driven turbines to drive the Mill’s machinery. As a result, RESD has also contacted Energy Ottawa who, after subsequently touring the Mill with Watson’s Mill Inc. representatives in early October 2007, have indicated an interest in further exploring the potential and economic viability of generating electricity in this location if RESD can obtain further information from Parks Canada regarding water flows and ongoing water rights. RESD has recently contacted Parks Canada who have agreed to provide this information.
City staff also
noted, as part of the due diligence work, that:
§ The property at 1135 Mill Street, between the Weavers House at 1131 Mill Street and the City owned the property at 1137 Mill Street (leased to the Millers Oven), was listed for sale at $339K and reportedly conditionally sold;
§ The property owned by the Estate of Dorothy Clapp at 1125 Clapp Lane, which property also abuts Bridge Street and Mill Street as a key entryway to Dickinson Square, was listed for sale at $699K;
§ The property owned by Maurice Holloway at the corner of Bridge Street & Mill Street across, which is directly across Mill Street from the Clapp property and abuts the west channel of the Rideau River, has reportedly been offered to the RVCA for $300K; and
§ The Manotick Village Plan, as set out in Volume 2c of the City’s Official Plan adopted under By-law 203-2003 City’s Official Plan, limits the proposed institutional uses and offices uses in the Historic Village East Sector to those under the existing zoning and provides for Council to examine the feasibility of relocating the RVCA offices and establishing a “Mill Quarter” based on commercial tourist/heritage type uses (accommodation, boutiques, galleries, craft and other specialty outlets, museums, restaurants and studios). Document 5 of this report provides further information on the Village Plan for Manotick.
On 17 October 2007, staff from the City’s
Cultural Services & Community Funding Branch, Parks & Recreation
Branch, Economic & Environmental Sustainability Branch, Rural Affairs
Office, and Real Property Asset Management Branch met with the Deputy City
Manger of Community and Protective Services Department to set a direction for
reporting back to Council by the end of November 2007 regarding options that provide for the RVCA’s Dickinson
Square properties to
remain under public ownership given the information in the initial draft of DSHMI’s Business Plan
and the information from the City’s due diligence work.
At the 17 October 2007 meeting, staff agreed that a report should be prepared for consideration in November 2007, by the Agricultural and Rural Affairs Committee, the Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee and Council which outlines and evaluates DSHMI’s draft Business Plan and any other potential City option for the City acquiring the RVCA’s Dickinson Square properties on the basis of objectives as follows:
· The preservation and enhancement of the unique enclave of heritage buildings in the Village of Manotick’s Dickinson Square after the RVCA divests its properties in that location;
· The continued operation of Watson’s Mill as a “living museum” by Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc.;
· The establishment of a Mill Quarter as envisioned by the Village Plan for Manotick set out in the City’s Official Plan;
· The preservation of Dickinson Square by formalizing and maintaining it as an open space, primarily for public use, to reflect the heritage character of the Mill Quarter and provide enhanced opportunities for heritage and cultural events as envisioned by DSHMI;
· The provision of effective public controls with respect to ensuring the development and use of properties in the Mill Quarter are consistent with the above objectives; and
·
The preservation and enhancement of the Dickinson
Square buildings and the square and the establishment of the Mill Quarter are
undertaken with no net impact on the City’s operating and capital budgets.
Representatives from the City’s Rural Affairs Office, the
Cultural Services and Community Funding Branch, and Real Estate Services
Division then attended the October 18th pubic meeting organized by
DSHMI and subsequently reviewed the second draft of DSHMI’s Business Plan.
DOCUMENT 4
DICKINSON SQUARE
HERITAGE MANAGEMENT INC.
(DSHMI)
PUBLIC MEETING INFORMATION
(Manotick Arena, Oct 18th, 2007)
v DSHMI is working towards the creation of a unique Heritage Cultural Centre in the historic Village of Manotick
v The Heritage Cultural Centre would provide opportunities and space for Arts, Heritage programming and Community activities.
v DSHMI is a Coalition of community-based organizations who regularly use the Square:
· Kiwanis of Manotick
· Manotick BIA
· Manotick Horticultural Society
· Manotick Art Association
· Manotick Messenger
· Rideau Historical Society
· Rideau Seniors’ Centre
· Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc
“To preserve and promote the unique heritage character of Dickinson Square for the benefit of the community and beyond.”
To work towards:
· City purchase of the buildings
·
Creation of Heritage Cultural Centre
· City of Ottawa Service Agreement
Remains as it is now, Ottawa’s only working industrial heritage site and only operating gristmill on Rideau Canal, now a World Heritage Site
Could be:
· 1st Floor - Relocated Mill Gift Shop expanded to new Square Gift Shop
· 2nd Floor - Heritage Cultural Centre Offices
Could become the new home of the Rideau Seniors’ Centre
Could have:
· 1st Floor - Social and economic interpretation and multi-purpose gallery
· 2nd Floor - Dickinson House Families interpretation, programming/meeting space
· 3rd Floor - Programming or Office
Could be reused as:
· 1st Floor - washrooms and programming - performing arts and group activities
· 2nd Floor - programming - children’s activities and meetings
· Possible future reconstruction of former wing for more programming space
Possible Uses:
· Dickinson Days
· Heritage gardens, Square interpretative plaques & connecting pathways
· Shakespeare in the Park
· Outdoor Market
· Heritage and Arts Camp
· Special events – Concerts, wedding, picnics
DSHMI Progress to Date
2006
· RVCA announces planned move to new headquarters
·
Save Our
Square Committee (SOS) created
· Public signs petition to Government of Ontario and Mayor Bob Chiarelli promises Dickinson Square will remain in public ownership
· Mayor Chiarelli and Steve Kanellakos, Deputy City Manager meet with DSHMI and commit to working with DSHMI to develop the Square
· Arts, Heritage and Culture Advisory Committee (AHCAC) passes motion supporting City purchase of Dickinson Square and DSHMI Management Contract
· DSHM incorporates (DSHMI) as Ontario charity
· RVCA and City sign debenture agreement and 18 month Option to Purchase begins with staff directed to report back to Council within 1 year
2007
· Strategic Planning Terms of Reference developed along with desired Catchment Area
· Interviews with individuals/groups in the Manotick and surrounding area & the Council of Heritage Organizations of Ottawa & the City undertakes a Building Audit
· DSHMI Board submits Interim Concept Plan to the City
· Based on this Plan, the City of Ottawa commits $40,000 as leverage for a CAHSP application for funding to develop DSHMI’s Concept Plan
· CAHSP grant denied. DSHMI meets with City of Ottawa to discuss options
· City staff:
§ commit to seeking approval from City Council for $40,000 for Business Plan
§ set timeline for submission of DSHMI Business Plan in order to be considered at Council
· Joint meeting of the boards of DSHMI and Watson’s Mill Manotick Inc. to explore future working relationships
· DSHMI hires consultants to assist in development of Business Plan
· City Council denies reallocation of funds for 10 cultural projects, including $40,000 for DSHMI Business Plan
· Public appeal for emergency funds for Business Plan
· DSHMI convinces RVCA to go for Ayers Bldg. designation
· DSHMI receives Draft Business Plan from consultants
· Receive community input at Open Forum
· Completion of Final Business Plan
· City staff report back to Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee on Nov. 20th and then onto Council on Nov. 28th
· DSHMI presents the Business Plan on Nov. 20th
§ Deputations from heritage organizations
· Council decision to purchase buildings considered during the 2008 budget process
· RVCA move to new HQ scheduled for December, 2007
· Creation of Dickinson Square Heritage Cultural Centre in 2008
DOCUMENT 5
EXTRACT
From
OFFICIAL PLAN
VOLUME 2C
VILLAGE PLANS
FORMER TOWNSHIP OF RIDEAU OFFICIAL PLAN
MANOTICK (AMENDMENT 3)
3. The Historic Village
East
Sector Uses
Mixed
Use
Built
Form - East Sector
Public
and Institutional Uses Limited
Parking
“Mill
Quarter"
Corporate Services
and Economic Development Committee Report 17 28 november 2007 |
|
Comité des services organisationnels et du
développement économique rapport 17 le 28 novembre 2007 |
|
|
|
Extract of draft Minutes 18 19 november 2007 |
|
Extrait de l’ébauche du procès-verbal 18 –
le 19 novembre 2007 |
MANOTICK
MILL QUARTER -
THE PROPOSED ACQUISITION OF LAND
QUARTIER DU MOULIN DE MANOTICK -
L'ACQUISTION DE TERRAIN PROPOSE
ACS2007-BTS-RPM-0045 Rideau-Goulbourn (21)
Councillor Hume wondered if Committee could deal with this item before recessing for the day.
Councillor Desroches indicated the item had been timed for consideration on the next day.
Councillor Hume assumed the item had been timed for the convenience of the Ward Councillor and indicated that if it suited Councillor Brooks, he would be happy to deal with the item.
The Committee Coordinator indicated there was one public delegation registered to speak on the item and that this person had been advised of the item’s timing.
Responding to a follow-up question from Councillor Bloess, the Committee Coordinator confirmed that the delegation had registered to speak in support of the report recommendations.
Councillor Hume indicated he would be happy to carry the item and that Councillor Brooks could advise his community accordingly.
Councillor Brooks expressed concurrence.
That this juncture, Committee voted to approve the report recommendations.
That the Corporate Services and
Economic Development Committee consider recommending that Council:
1. Approve the establishment of a Manotick
Mill Quarter Corporation (holding company), as described in this report, in
accordance with the Business Case Study set out in Document 1 attached hereto;
2. Approve the acquisition in fee simple
of two (2) parcels of land consisting of a combined land area of approximately
4056 sq. m. owned by the Rideau Valley Conservation Authority (RVCA) and known
as the Dickinson House, the Carriage House and Weaver's House being Parcel
"A" and the Ayer's Building being Parcel "B", as shown on
the Annex "A" sketch attached to this report, for the consideration
of $1,400,000 plus GST subject to final adjustments on closing and the
following condition. The RVCA would be required to enter into a heritage
easement agreement with the City for the Watson's Mill property, being Parcel
"C", as shown on the Annex "A" sketch attached to this
report, and to agree to transfer the Watson's Mill property to Watson's Mill
Manotick Inc. for $1 subject to the City being provided with an option to
purchase this property for $1 if Watson's Mill Manotick Inc. at any time offers
the Mill property for lease or sale;
3. Approve the acquisition in fee simple
of a 2144 sq. m. parcel of land, owned by the Estate of Anna Dorothy Clapp,
described as Part of Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower; Part Lot 1
N/S Bridge Street, Plan 15 As In NG13177; City of Ottawa (PIN: 03903-1114) and
being Parcel "D" as shown on the Annex "A" sketch attached
to this report, for the consideration of $590,000 plus GST subject to final
adjustments on closing;
4. Approve the acquisition in fee simple
of a 1648 sq. m. parcel of land, owned by Maurice Holloway, described as Part
of Lot 1, Concession A, Broken Front, North Gower, As In NG10893; City of
Ottawa (PIN: 03903-1158) and being Parcel "E" as shown on the Annex
"A" sketch attached to this report, for the consideration of $250,000
plus GST subject to final adjustments on closing;
5. Approve the transfer of the properties,
shown as Parcels "A", "B", "D" &
"E" on the Annex "A" sketch attached to this report to the
Manotick Mill Quarter Corporation subject to the repayment and heritage and
easement conditions and the public use covenants set out more particularly in
Document 2 of this report;
6. Direct staff to continue to pursue with
Watson's Mill Manotick Inc., Energy Ottawa and Parks Canada, the potential for
and economic viability of generating electrical power at Watson's Mill; and
7. Approve a grant to Dickinson Heritage
Management Inc. (DSHMI) in an amount not to exceed $25,000 to be used to offset
the actual costs incurred by DSHMI in the preparation of its business plan as
described in this report.
CARRIED