6.       PROPERTY ACQUISITION – NATIONAL CAPITAL COMMISSION – LEDBURY AVENUE/ALBION ROAD, OTTAWA


acquisition de propriété – commission de la capitale nationale – avenue ledbury/chemin albion, ottawa

 

COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS

 

That Council approve:

 

1.                  The acquisition in fee simple of a vacant parcel of land consisting of approximately 7.40 ha owned by the National Capital Commission, described as Lots 3 & 4, Plan 198, Part of Lots 5, 6 & 7, Plan 198, Part of Lot 2, Concession 3, Rideau Front, Geographic Township of Gloucester, City of Ottawa, shown on the attached Annex “A”, for the consideration of $1,830,000 plus GST, subject to final survey and adjustments on closing.

 

2.                  The funds in excess of $1,000,000 to be allocated from the Cash in Lieu of Parkland Reserve Fund.

 

 

RECOMMENDATIONS DU COMITÉ

 

Que le Conseil approuve :

 

1.         l’acquisition en fief simple d’un terrain vacant d’une superficie approximative de 7,40 hectares appartenant à la Commission de la capitale nationale, décrit comme les lots 3 et 4, plan 198, une partie des lots 5, 6 et 7, plan 198, et une partie du lot 2, concession 3, façade rivière Rideau, canton géographique de Gloucester, ville d’Ottawa, illustré à l’annexe A, moyennant la somme de 1 830 000 $ (TPS non comprise), sous réserve du levé final et de rectifications à la signature.

 

2.         les fonds dépassant t financier des frais relatifs aux terrains à vocation de parc. 1 million de dollars seront alloués à partir du fonds de réserve du règlemen

 

 

DOCUMENTATION

 

1.         Chief Corporate Services Officer’s report dated 20 March 2006
(ACS2006-CRS-RPM-0032).

2.         Extract of Draft Minute, 04 April 2006.

 


Report to/Rapport au :

 

Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee

Comité des services organisationnels et du développement économique

 

and Council / et au Conseil

 

20 March 2006 / le 20 mars 2006

 

Submitted by/Soumis par : Greg Geddes, Chief Corporate Services Officer/

Chef des Services généraux

 

Contact Person/Personne ressource : Gordon MacNair, Acting Manager, Real Estate Services

Real Property Asset Management/Gestion des actifs des biens immobiliers

(613) 580-2424 x21217, gordon.macnair@ottawa.ca

 

River/Rivière (16)

Ref N°: ACS2006-CRS-RPM-0032

 

 

SUBJECT:

PROPERTY ACQUISITION – NATIONAL CAPITAL COMMISSION – LEDBURY AVENUE/ALBION ROAD, OTTAWA

 

 

OBJET :

acquisition de propriété – commission de la capitale nationale – avenue ledbury/chemin albion, ottawa

 

 

REPORT RECOMMENDATIONS

 

That the Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee recommend Council approve:

 

1.         The acquisition in fee simple of a vacant parcel of land consisting of approximately 7.40 ha owned by the National Capital Commission, described as Lots 3 & 4, Plan 198, Part of Lots 5, 6 & 7, Plan 198, Part of Lot 2, Concession 3, Rideau Front, Geographic Township of Gloucester, City of Ottawa, shown on the attached Annex “A”, for the consideration of $1,830,000 plus GST, subject to final survey and adjustments on closing.

 

2.         The funds in excess of $1,000,000 to be allocated from the Cash in Lieu of Parkland Reserve Fund.

 

 

RECOMMANDATIONS DU RAPPORT

 

Que le Comité des services organisationnels et du développement économique recommande au Conseil d’approuver :

 

1.         l’acquisition en fief simple d’un terrain vacant d’une superficie approximative de 7,40 hectares appartenant à la Commission de la capitale nationale, décrit comme les lots 3 et 4, plan 198, une partie des lots 5, 6 et 7, plan 198, et une partie du lot 2, concession 3, façade rivière Rideau, canton géographique de Gloucester, ville d’Ottawa, illustré à l’annexe A, moyennant la somme de 1 830 000 $ (TPS non comprise), sous réserve du levé final et de rectifications à la signature.

 

2.         les fonds dépassant 1 million de dollars seront alloués à partir du fonds de réserve du règlement financier des frais relatifs aux terrains à vocation de parc.

 

 

BACKGROUND

 

In 2004, Council approved the Sportsfield Strategy Report (ACS2004-PEO-COM-004) prepared by the Parks and Recreation Branch of the Community and Protective Services Department.  This report outlined the Branch’s strategy to address the overwhelming demand for sportsfields across the City.

 

Currently, sportsfield needs and deficiencies are being addressed firstly through conversions and upgrading of existing fields as capital costs can be minimized and the resulting increased inventory can be secured relatively quickly.  This approach has been the Branch’s priority throughout 2005 and 2006 and will result in 19 field conversions, 2 soccer and 2 ultimate new field developments; exclusive of new fields being financed and development through new park growth and development charges.  Secondly, additional resources have been secured by Public Works and Services Department (PWSD) to improve the quality of existing fields and maintenance standards, permitting greater and longer use of play.  The rehabilitation of fields that are in unsatisfactory condition can be placed back into the inventory to ease the unmet demand.  Lastly, in order to address the shortfall, the Branch is committed to acquiring, where possible, additional lands for sportsfield development, either through purchase, land exchange or partnership with local sports organizations.

 

Prior to the 19 February 2006, Health Recreation and Social Services (HRSS) Committee meeting, members of Council received an Information Previously Distributed memo (ACS2006-CPS-PAR-003), entitled “Study of Potential Sportsfield Sites”.  This item was deferred to the 6 April 2006 Committee meeting, allowing an opportunity for the standing committee members to seek further clarification. This report identifies potential candidate sites for sportsfield development including the acquisition of the subject site should the opportunity arise.

 

Needs Assessment

 

It is estimated by the Eastern Ontario District Soccer Association and the Ottawa-Carleton Soccer Association an estimated 38,500 participate in the sport of soccer: 5,000 registered by the Ottawa-Carleton Ultimate Association, 900 in the eastern Ontario Rugby League and 5,000 in the Touch Football Ontario, National Capital Amateur Football Association and Flag Football Ontario, all based and using fields in Ottawa.  The elevated participation numbers and use is due in part to sportsfield trends whereby these activities are a relatively affordable sport compared to other sports, the push towards a healthy and more active lifestyle, greater female participation in sports, and a more diverse City with cultural preferences increasing interest in such sports.  Soccer participation in Ottawa, particularly at the competitive level, has increased over the past five years and registration is expected to continue to grow.  As identified in the Sportsfield Strategy, a total of 124 soccer fields should be developed during the period to 2011.  A total of 70 soccer fields are recommended for the Central District for the period up to 2011 to respond to existing field deficiencies, which does not include accommodation of new growth demand.  Almost half of the organizations consulted for the Sportsfield Strategy stated they have waiting lists or have turned away potential players due to lack of field time.

 

The Strategy also recommends the City continue to add ultimate fields on an annual basis to keep pace with demand. Given the recent growth in the sport, it is recommended that the City and Ottawa-Carleton Ultimate Association work co-operatively to monitor growth in registration in the sport as a means to enable more effective planning for field requirements.

 

Rugby, as a growing sport, requires development of new facilities.  As recommended by the Strategy, provision of a dedicated game and/or practice facility should be located centrally, as players are located throughout the City of Ottawa

 

As the proportion of youth participation increases, there will be a need to locate facilities that are accessible to youth within their communities, by public transit as well as private vehicles.

 

 

DISCUSSION

 

In planning new sportsfield facilities, geographic accessibility to multiple modes of transport is required.  These facilities should be as accessible as possible to all participant groups within the City, including youth, adults, disabled persons, minority groups and lower income households.

 

The Sportsfield Strategy identified the central area (urban area inside the greenbelt) with the largest deficiency in available sportsfields for area residents.  This is not surprising given that older established communities provide few vacant properties.  As well, existing properties are typically redeveloped for their highest and best use.  Therefore, the opportunity for sportsfields in the central area becomes a rare and unaffordable option.

 

The subject site is adjacent to the City’s existing Ledbury Park, that was the subject of a recent community effort to revitalize their park, by partnering with the private sector in building a new play area.  It also involved refreshing the existing Ledbury Community building that houses community meetings and programs.  Residents of the area would benefit from an expanded green space and sportsfields that could be allocated to sports leagues as well as the community.  The potential exists to redevelop the two sites at the same time in order to maximize site efficiencies, expand the green open space and develop active sports.

 

At the request of Community and Protective Services Department, Parks and Recreation Branch, negotiations with the National Capital Commission (NCC) were undertaken.  The subject parcel is located at the end of Albion Road North and is municipally known as 1311 Ledbury Avenue, City of Ottawa.  The parcel consists of 7.40 ha of vacant land and is adjacent to the railway marshalling yards known as Walkley Yard. The parcel is currently zoned UR – Urban Reserve. The purpose of this zone is to, in part, permit a range of public, recreational and open space uses which do not compromise the outcome of the secondary planning studies required to determine the ultimate, major urban uses of this land.  Permitted uses typically include, a botanical garden, a building or use by a government institution or agency, a cemetery, a day care, emergency service, museum and a park.  A park use is consistent with the General Urban Area designation within the City’s Official Plan.

 

Further, there is a restriction imposed by the railway industry and supported by case law for lands abutting rail yards. Typically, a 30 m zone of influence is imposed from the lot line to restrict any development and further, a 300 m zone of influence from the lot line to restrict residential development.  The subject site is effectively restricted from residential development as a result.

 

An independent appraisal completed on behalf of the City resulted in a market value estimate of $247,000/ha for the 7.40 ha site.  In addition, the City reviewed two independent appraisals completed on behalf of the NCC each resulting in a market value estimate of $247,000/ha.  Negotiations with the NCC have resulted in an agreement to purchase the parcel for the consideration of $1,830,000 subject to the City completing its environmental and geotechnical due diligence with regard to this site. 

 

This acquisition is recommended for approval.

 

 

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPLICATIONS

 

The NCC has held the site as a vacant parcel for many years. In the 1970’s both the City of Ottawa and the Regional Municipality of Ottawa-Carleton used this site as a snow disposal facility.  The City has undertaken a peer review of the Phase I/II Environmental Site Assessment Reports, prepared on behalf of the NCC and have concluded there are no environmental issues of concern for the subject site and the proposed park use.  However, the City will be provided sixty (60) days from the 12 April 2006 Council meeting, to complete their environmental and geotechnical due diligence with regard to this site.

 

 

CONSULTATION

 

Sportsfield stakeholders were consulted in both the Sportsfield Strategy and the Potential Sportsfield Sites Study.  The City will work with sports groups to identify partnership opportunities available for the development of these new fields. The Ward Councillor is aware of this recommendation.

 

 


FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS

 

Funding of $1,000,000 is available in the Parks and Recreation approved Capital Budget Project, Land Acquisition – Sportfields account. The remaining funds are available from the Cash in lieu of Parkland Reserve Fund.

 

 

SUPPORTING DOCUMENTATION

 

Attached, as Annex “A” is a sketch showing the site to be acquired.

 

 

DISPOSITION

 

Following Council’s approval, Real Property Asset Management and Legal Services Branches will finalize the transaction.

 


 



 

            PROPERTY ACQUISITION – NATIONAL CAPITAL COMMISSION – LEDBURY AVENUE/ALBION ROAD, OTTAWA

acquisition de propriété – commission de la capitale nationale – avenue ledbury/chemin albion, ottawa

ACS2006-CRS-RPM-0032

 

Timothy Lane noted this land is being offered to the City by the National Capital Commission (NCC) at a price of approximately $100,000 per acre.  He then made reference to a document he had obtained, which spoke to the capital costs to buy land for the Light Rail Transit (LRT) system’s storage and maintenance yard.  This document indicated a 40 acre parcel of land adjacent to the subject site, which would need to be purchased from CPR if the storage yard were to be built at the Walkley yard, would cost in the range of $200,000 per acre.  Mr. Lane noted the subjected site has been used as a snow dump in the past, so there may be some contamination from that use.  However, the CPR yard was used as a railway yard for nearly 50 years and is certain to have some contamination.  He questioned why, if the City is buying the subject land from the NCC for $100,000 per acre, they would be willing to pay twice as much for the abutting land, which is likely to have more contamination and should therefore not be worth as much. 

 

Des Doran, representing a Community Centre for Ottawa’s Black Community, advised his association had been meeting for some time to plan the social, cultural, and economic development of the black community.  Mr. Doran, referencing events that have taken place in places such as Toronto and also youth spending long hours in non-productive ways (e.g. such as hanging out at the Rideau Centre), spoke of the need for a cultural centre for the black community, with programs that are structured in a culturally sensitive way.  He said he had met with the NCC concerning the availability of land in Ottawa and this was one of the sites that had been mentioned.  Mr. Doran said his group was pleased the City was acquiring this land and expressed the hope a specific use was not already identified for this land.  He asked that his group’s interest in this site be recognized, with a view to discussing at some future date participation in creating a black cultural social economic development centre for Ottawa’s black community.

 

Vice Chair McRae noted, as the staff report indicated, this land was being purchased for the express purpose of sports field development.  Mr. Doran remarked the use of the land for sports fields would be consistent with their proposed use, as they plan to incorporate sports fields and facilities in the centre.  Vice Chair McRae advised she is the Councillor for the Ward in which this land is located and, although this land is intended for City activities, she is working on a big initiative in the Banff-Ledbury area.  She indicated if Mr. Doran wished to contact her about this initiative, she would be pleased to discuss this with him.

 

David Jeanes, Transport 2000 expressed his support for the City’s acquisition of this land.  He said when he first saw this land for sale, he contacted the NCC and was advised it was offered to the City but the City was not interested. This caused him concern.  He explained this land abuts the Walkley Yard (i.e. 6 acres of land the City has already purchased) and also abuts other land the City may purchase from CPR for the LRT storage yard (i.e. if the City decides to use the Walkley Yard).

 

Speaking to the intended use of the subject land by the City, Mr. Jeanes noted this area is currently under study by the East-West Light Rail Environmental Assessment (EA) and is zoned Industrial.  He expressed his opinion the subject land should have been considered under the Light Rail EA.  He encouraged the City to consider other uses for this land before committing to a sports facility (e.g. the best use of this land might be as a parking lot for employees of light rail yard).  Further, he cautioned that a recreational use so close to an active rail yard may create hazards to human life and this should be taken into consideration before committing to a sports facility.

 

In response to questions from Councillor Hume, Vice Chair McRae confirmed the subject land is in fact adjacent to the existing Ledbury Park and there is also a community pool just up the street.

 

The staff recommendation was then approved.

 

That the Corporate Services and Economic Development Committee recommend Council approve:

 

1.   The acquisition in fee simple of a vacant parcel of land consisting of approximately 7.40 ha owned by the National Capital Commission, described as Lots 3 & 4, Plan 198, Part of Lots 5, 6 & 7, Plan 198, Part of Lot 2, Concession 3, Rideau Front, Geographic Township of Gloucester, City of Ottawa, shown on the attached Annex “A”, for the consideration of $1,830,000 plus GST, subject to final survey and adjustments on closing.

 

2.   The funds in excess of $1,000,000 to be allocated from the Cash in Lieu of Parkland Reserve Fund.

 

                                                                                                CARRIED