Final Version -
January 10, 2007
211 Ottawa Launch
Connecting People
to Services
Business
Case
Contents
Executive Summary … 1
Introduction … 4
Benefits … 5
·
For people
·
For service organizations
·
For governments
·
For society
Progress to date … 11
·
History and context
·
Community consultations
·
Initial 211 Ottawa plans
·
Recent developments
211 Ottawa Initial
Operating
Model … 15
·
Governance and management
·
Start-up activities
·
Initial Operations
·
Ongoing community consultations
·
Launch year operational budget
·
Project milestones
Immediate
Next Steps … 19
Appendices
… 20
A. Funding
Requirements
B.
Risks and Mitigation Strategies
C.
References …
Executive Summary
211 Ottawa is part of a provincial and national vision to
enhance access to human and community services for all Canadians. |
is an easy-to-remember telephone number that connects people to a full
range of non-emergency social, health, community and government services. By
calling 211 Ottawa, an individual would immediately reach a bilingual
information and referral specialist, trained to assess their needs, to understand
their questions and concerns, and to link them to the best available
information and services, all on a confidential basis.
Research and the experience of communities already served by 211, shows
that this service:
·
Ensures people get help faster in times of personal need or difficulty;
·
Enables human and social service organizations to be more productive and
to better anticipate the needs of their clients;
·
Helps governments to provide services.
For example, the 211 service complements 311 municipal service and
reduces the burden on 911 service during emergencies;
·
Creates a powerful social policy and planning tool by consolidating
information about the services Canadians request and access.
Moreover,
according to Deloitte & Touche, if the 211 service was implemented across
Canada, every $1 invested would generate $2.4 of benefit.
Discussions about
bringing a 211 service to Ottawa began five years ago with extensive community
consultations. A feasibility study and
a review of organizational capacity were also completed early on. Then in 2005, a comprehensive business and
technical plan was developed, which requested sustained funding over five years
to launch the service. Unfortunately,
due to budgetary constraints at United Way/Centraide Ottawa, the municipal and
provincial levels of government and other funding sources, this magnitude of
funding was not forthcoming at the time.
In early 2006,
United Way organizations across Ontario banded together to collectively call on
the Government of Ontario to make “211 accessible to all residents of
Ontario”. The Government answered this
call. It provided a $3 million grant over 3 years to Findhelp to expand the
online service delivery of 211 Ontario.ca, an internet-based directory of the
60,000 human services available in Ontario.
It also ear-marked $1.4 million for the call centre start-up activities
required to launch the 211 service.
This funding is conditional on local 211 initiatives first obtaining the
operational funding necessary to provide the 211 service for at least one year.
It represents an unprecedented opportunity to kick-start local 211 initiatives,
thereby laying the foundation for a province-wide 211 system.
The Ontario211
project team has been working closely with the 211 teams in Ottawa, Thunder
Bay, Halton Region and Windsor to help build the capacity necessary to
implement a 211 service in their communities.
Once operational, the 211 services in these communities would join
existing 211 operations in Collingwood, Niagara Region and Toronto to form the
backbone of a 211 system, serving more than 50 percent of Ontarians.
The 211 Ottawa service will
play a pivotal role in this province-wide system in a number of ways. The plan
is for 211 Ottawa to serve citizens across the entire area served by the 613
area code. This would encompass most of
Eastern Ontario, including Kingston, Renfrew, Cornwall, Brockville and
Belleville. The 211 for All Ontario
report also calls for the 211 Ottawa service to provide information to
francophone Ontarians through the 211Ontario.ca web portal and its call centre.
Therefore, 211 Ottawa would become the focal point for French language services
in a consolidated network of call centres, offering bilingual 211 services
across the province.
The Distress Centre of Ottawa and Region (DCOR) will
be the managing agency for 211 Ottawa service, heading up the start-up
activities and overseeing ongoing operations. With its commitment to community
service, entrepreneurial approach and extensive call centre experience, it has
the management strengths to meet the national licensing and accreditation
standards required to operate a 211 service in Canada. The DCOR’s work will be guided by a 211
Advisory Group, comprised of representatives from the United Way/Centraide Ottawa,
the City of Ottawa and other community stakeholders.
It is anticipated that the Community Information
Centre (CIC) will be responsible for the development and maintenance of the
bilingual database in a contractual agreement with DCOR. The CIC is highly
regarded for its database and directory expertise. It is the publisher of the widely used Directory of Ottawa Community Services and the developer of a
bilingual database of 1400 community services. The CIC currently provides local
information for provincial initiatives such as Telehealth, employment,
immigration and youth justice services.
To fine-tune and adjust any initial service
issues, this business case proposes to introduce the 211 Ottawa service on a
soft launch basis on October 1, 2007, followed by a formal public launch in
early February 2008. 211 Ottawa will
operate from 8:00 am to 6:00 pm, seven days a week during its first year,
moving to 24/7 service in the second year.
Based on the experience of other 211 centres it is estimated that in
year 1 Ottawa would potentially be responding to 72,000 calls. The total
estimated operating costs for year 1 are $570,735. These costs will cover management, staffing and training as well as telephony, IT, office space,
translation and multilingual interpretation services.
To meet the provincial government’s condition on 211 start-up funding,
the 211 Ottawa team must move quickly to secure operational funding for the
launch year before March 31, 2007.
Introduction
“The best thing about 211 is that people, not
machines, answer my call, and the staff take time to provide me with the
information I need.”
A 211 caller
|
Imagine you are a new immigrant to Canada, who has just settled in
Ottawa with your family. You want to
know where you can get the latest information about the immigration
process. You are interested in finding
out about clubs or events to meet other people new to Ottawa. You would like
your teenagers to try-out for soccer in a local league. You also have a young
autistic child and want to join a support group for parents.
You could use the telephone directory to see if the information is
there. You could call around to
different government departments or social service agencies. But, you would likely contact several people
who cannot help you. You may get stuck
trying to get answers using an interactive voice response system. You could leave several voice mail messages
to no avail. In the end, you could
spend many hours on the telephone and still not have the answers you need.
Or you could call 211 Ottawa.
211 is an easy-to-remember telephone number that connects people to a
full range of non-emergency social, health, community and government services.
By calling 211 Ottawa, an individual would immediately reach an information and
referral specialist, trained to assess their needs, to understand their
questions and concerns, and to link them to the best available information and
services. With one simple call, people in Ottawa would receive expert and
completely confidential assistance, from a real person, in French, English or
the caller’s preferred language.
The 211 service is licensed, meaning that new 211 service providers must
apply to the 211 Standards Review and Licensing Panel to become an approved 211
service provider. The service is also
accredited and must meet nationally defined standards, established by
InformCanada and the Alliance of Information and Referral Systems or AIRS. AIRS is a professional association of more
than 1000 community information and referral providers across Canada and the
United States. These 211 standards
include exacting requirements for:
·
Service delivery
·
Resource database
·
Reports and measures
·
Cooperative relationships, and
·
Organizational governance, administration, training and outreach.
The first 211 service in Canada was launched in Toronto in 2002. Since
then, the service has been introduced in Edmonton, Calgary, Niagara Region and
Simcoe County. The experience of these communities demonstrates that the 211
service is highly valued by callers, service organizations and governments
alike. It saves time, eliminates
frustration, and makes everyone’s job much easier and more efficient.
This business case proposes the launch of the 211 service in the Ottawa
area as part of a province-wide initiative to introduce 211 throughout
Ontario. It outlines the benefits of
211 to individuals, service organizations, and governments. It describes the research conducted to date
on the enormous potential of 211 to bring new effectiveness to the provision of
social services.
In addition, this business case traces the progress that has been
achieved to date in bringing the 211 service to Ottawa and Ontario. Important relationships and partnerships
have been established, community consultations have taken place, and a
highly-qualified service provider has been identified.
This case further describes how the 211 service will be launched in
Ottawa. It provides an overview of the
governance structure for the service and details how the Distress Centre of
Ottawa and Region will manage the service. Key project milestones and funding
requirements are also presented.
Finally, this plan outlines the immediate next steps.
211
Ottawa will become the first stop for people needing advice and
information on community, health and social services, such as: ·
Food, shelter and clothing assistance ·
Employment services ·
Access to permanent housing ·
Mental health support ·
Home support ·
Child care ·
Legal and correctional services ·
Services for newcomers to Canada ·
Drug and alcohol intervention and rehabilitation ·
Counselling and support services for individuals
and families ·
Services for people with physical or
developmental disabilities and their families ·
Health services ·
Services for seniors ·
Emergency shelters ·
Volunteer opportunities ·
Social and recreational programs ·
Community development initiatives
Benefits
The 211 service enables people to get
the help they need faster and easier
People
who call 211 value the services it provides.
According to caller surveys recently conducted in Niagara, Simcoe
County and Toronto: ·
97% of 211 callers
received the help they needed ·
100% would call 211
again ·
100% would recommend the
211 service to their family and friends. Source: 211
Ontario Q2 report, April to June 2006 |
As the communities served by the 211 service throughout North America
have discovered, 211 benefits people the most.
An impact study1 conducted following the first full year of operation
of Toronto’s 211 service, concluded that 211 ensures that people receive
significantly better service when seeking help about community, health and
public resources. For example, the study found that:
·
People can access community services more quickly and effectively. 211 Information and Referral (I&R)
Specialists are trained to provide high quality and reliable information,
customized to the specific needs of each caller. As a result, 211 callers receive informed choices about the types
of available services;
·
Community and public service organization staff refer clients to 211,
knowing that their clients will receive the right information;
·
People spend less time, are less frustrated, and become less discouraged
in finding and accessing the help they need. They also find out about services
they did not know existed before calling 211;
·
People who are more comfortable speaking their own language can be
helped through the multilingual capacity of the 211 service.
This study also found that a 211 service encourages people to help
themselves. They are able to take
action right away. They can call or
search online for information. They know where to call or look the next time
they, a friend or family member, need
help. And they do not have to navigate
their own way forward in an increasingly complex, often overwhelming maze of
services, organizations and government departments. Because they receive information targeted to their individual needs, 211 callers are better
able to prioritize their actions and plan accordingly.
211 enables service organizations to save time, to
reduce costs and to better anticipate the needs of their clients
Research and the experience of communities already served by 211 shows
that the service can also prove an invaluable tool to community and human
service agencies and organizations.
“I am 71 and there are
people I know that can’t see well, and it just helps to have 211. A lot of people out there don’t know what
help is available. I tell every
senior citizen I know about you.”
A 211 caller
|
First, the 211 service reduces the number of inappropriate referrals
that community and human services agencies typically receive. Therefore,
community and human service workers can concentrate more of their time on
providing core services to clients. They can quickly redirect callers to 211 if
callers do not qualify for their services. And workers can call 211 themselves,
becoming more effective in helping their clients. Almost one-fifth (18 percent) of the callers to 211 Toronto are
staff from other agencies looking for information to help their clients.
To quantify the impact of these efficiencies, 211Ontario.ca analyzed the
costs and benefits of implementing “an efficient, coordinated human service information
system accessed through a fully searchable, web-enabled directory”2 that enables
public and human service practitioners to access information about the 60,000
services available in Ontario.
Measuring only direct and quantifiable benefits, this analysis showed
that these front-line workers would save an average of six hours every week on
searching for information for their clients.
Second, a 211 service creates a single repository of information,
whereby extensive data about human and social services is collected, maintained
and updated on a regular basis. This
reduces duplication of effort. It also
improves reporting on the demand for services, allowing organizations to better
identify any gaps in meeting the needs of their clients. By consolidating the
collection of data and eliminating duplication of effort, the 211Ontario.ca
cost-benefit analysis3 further demonstrated that the 211 service would:
·
Increase the efficiency of data collection and reduce paper work, saving
service organizations more than $300,000 every year;
·
Decrease the time spent on data collection and maintenance, saving a
total of almost $4 million once the system reaches full efficiency after two
years of operation.
211 service helps governments to provide better
services everyday and especially during a crisis.
In addition to improving service access and delivery for individuals and
service organizations, the implementation of 211 offers government significant
cost-saving opportunities:
“Finding needed services can be a daunting task for
many people … difficulties in navigating the province’s under-resourced and
fragmented mental health care system can leave people frustrated or
overwhelmed, and contribute to delays in receiving appropriate assistance …
The Provincial Centre of Excellence for Child
and Youth Mental Health at CHEO
|
Equally important, the 211 service complements the 311 service. In
Ottawa, the 311 service has proved very useful in providing access to
non-emergency municipal government services.
Similarly, the 211 service would provide people with information and
referral about all human services and programs, regardless of whether these are
delivered by governments or by non-government providers.
A 211 service has also been found to be an
invaluable resource in times of crisis.
During the 2003 outbreak of SARS in Toronto, the
city’s 211 service experienced large increases in call volume and worked
closely with public health agencies to deal with the crisis and its aftermath.
The service also remained fully operational during the 2003 power blackout in
Toronto, despite a large spike in calls.
The experience of Toronto and other communities shows that in a crisis
or emergency, 211 can:
·
Identify and direct resources to high
priority places;
·
Provide critical reassurance and support
to callers;
·
Help mobilize and manage volunteers, cash
and in-kind donations;
·
Serve as an intake point on behalf of
government agencies;
·
Offer a sustained connection to help
people whose lives are dramatically affected
by community
crises as 211 becomes part of longer-term recovery efforts.
Additionally, 211 reduces the burden on the 911 system. It protects the integrity of the 911 service
during emergencies by diverting the public to an easy-to-remember number for
non-emergency inquiries and services. In fact, the development of 211 in the
U.S. has emerged as an integral component of community preparedness following
the attacks of September 11, 2001.
211 offers important new
social assets and economic efficiencies
In communities where the
211 service is available, the benefits have been profound from both a social
and an economic perspective. The 211 service benefits all citizens because it
promotes an integrated social infrastructure that supports people in times of
personal need or community crisis.
Moreover, by systematically tracking the reasons why people call 211
and the services they require, 211 creates a powerful new social policy and
planning tool – accurate, real-time need and demand data. Governments and other
providers of social and health services can use this information to identify
service gaps and gauge the impact of emerging trends. This enables social and
health service providers to deploy their resources more effectively.
The economic
advantages of 211 are equally remarkable. In 2005, United Way of Canada secured
the pro bono assistance of Deloitte to undertake a study of the costs and
benefits of implementing a national 211 service. The Deloitte report4 outlined considerable savings for individuals,
governments and other organizations.
For example, it showed that quantifiable
benefits would total $71 million annually, with $31 million accruing to
individuals, $22 million to organizations and $18 million to taxpayers.
Overall, total benefits would exceed total costs by a factor of 2.4 to one. In other words, every $1 invested in the 211
service would generate $2.4 of benefit.
The following
chart outlines the estimated future value of investments in the 211 service
from national, provincial and regional (Ottawa and its surrounding communities)
perspectives:
National5 |
Provincial6 |
Ottawa Region7 |
Assumes baseline scenario of 10
information centres providing 24/7 service |
Assumes 211Ontario service is a
public Ontario-wide, web-enabled resource |
Assumes 211 Ottawa would be one of
the 10 information centres across Canada |
Net Present Value of $202 million
over 10 years |
Net benefit of + $1.3 million in
Year 1, +$8 million over 3 years |
Net Present Value of + $20 million
over 10 years |
Investment would be paid back
within 2.53 years |
Future net benefits of more than
$5.1 million annually |
Investment would be paid back
within 2.53 years. |
To date, the City of Ottawa and United Way/Centraide Ottawa
have invested more than $146,000 to bring the 211 service to the citizens
of Ottawa
History and Context
The first 211 service in
North America was introduced in Atlanta, Georgia in 1997 and Atlanta's success
inspired many other communities to look at the feasibility of a similar
service.
In Ottawa, a 1999 study
by Comgate Engineering concluded that a 211 information service would be the
ideal option to meet the needs of people living in Canada’s growing national
capital. The study identified more than
50 telephone numbers used to access information or services in Ottawa and 20
existing information directories or referral services.
In June 2000, an
application was submitted to the CRTC jointly by a coalition consisting of
United Way/Centraide Canada, InformCanada, United Way of Greater Toronto and
Community Information Toronto. This coalition requested that an 'N11' code be
assigned for non-commercial use across Canada for information and referral to
community, social, health and government services.
In August 2001, the CRTC
approved the use of the 211 telephone number in those Canadian communities
complying with the Commission's criteria, including municipal support and a
community-based approach to defining and establishing the service.
In November 2001, the
Ottawa City Council approved a motion to support, in principle, the concept of
211 as a “coordinated information mechanism for accessing information and
referral services that serve the residents of Ottawa.”
Ottawa Community Consultations
Consultations with
community stakeholders in Ottawa began in December, 2001 with a meeting hosted
by United Way/Centraide Ottawa and the City of Ottawa. The meeting welcomed 65
participants representing 37 different community stakeholders. Most of the
concerns raised related to next steps in the development of 211, notably the
inclusion of agencies in the process, sustainable funding, and ensuring that
211 enhances existing community services.
Community consultations
continued and were subsequently captured in a 2003 Feasibility Study. This feasibility study, funded by the City
of Ottawa ($50,000) and United Way/Centraide Ottawa ($25,000), laid the
groundwork for continued collaboration in the planning and implementation of
211 Ottawa.
“I believe that 211 Ottawa will become an important
resource for all members of our community.
It will enable people to call just one, convenient number to reach a
bilingual professional, trained to help point them in the right
direction. That same convenient and
professional assistance will be available to community support volunteers and
staff too, helping them to help their clients faster and more efficiently.”
Louise Martin, Executive Director, The Good
Companions
|
Initial 211 Ottawa Plans
The 2003 Feasibility
Study was followed by a July 2004 Review of Organizational Capacity, funded by
United Way/Centraide Ottawa with a $27, 430 investment. This review:
It also included a
capacity assessment of the organizations, which had expressed an interest in
delivering the 211 service. This
capacity assessment, undertaken by third party consultants, was based on each
organization’s response to 130 questions, supporting documentation, interviews
with six other community groups and site visits.
The assessment
recommended harnessing the infrastructure of the Distress Centre of Ottawa and
Region (DCOR) as the managing agency for the delivery of the 211 Ottawa
service. The DCOR was found to have the
greatest strengths in terms of its governance, management and administration,
and extensive call centre operations
experience. It delivers four
services: The Ottawa Distress Line, the
Outaouoais Distress Line, the Champlain District Mental Health Crisis Line, and
the Grey Bruce Mental Health Crisis Line.
Building on the
importance of experience and expertise, the review also recommended that the
Community Information Center of Ottawa (CIC) be selected as the 211 Ottawa
database provider. The CIC annually produces The Directory of Ottawa Community Services, maintains a bilingual
database of 1400 community services and provides local information to
provincial portals. The CIC has also
contributed to the development of francophone records, both at a local and
provincial level.
In September 2004, the
development of a business case and plan began.
This work, conducted by Jonquil Eyre Consulting and Associates, was
funded by the City of Ottawa ($26,000) and the United Way/Centraide Ottawa
($17,600).
Jonquil Eyre Consulting
and Associates was guided in these efforts by the 211 Project Management Team,
comprised of representatives from the City of Ottawa, United Way/Centraide
Ottawa, and the DCOR. People with
resource development experience also contributed their expertise to ensure that
211 would build on existing, long-term and strategic opportunities and
relationships. The business case,
business plan and detailed implementation plan were completed on April 28, 2005
and subsequently reviewed by community stakeholders through meetings conducted
in June 2005.
At this time, the 211
Ottawa Project Management Team agreed that funding for a minimum of five years
should be in place in preparation for the launch of 211 Ottawa. Unfortunately, due to budgetary constraints,
the required level of funding was not immediately forthcoming from United
Way/Centraide Ottawa, the City of Ottawa, the Government of Ontario and other
funding sources.
Recent developments
“It was great that I could talk to a staff member in
my language, and get to know more about government services. I feel more confident now after calling
211.”
A 211
caller
|
In early 2006, the 211
Ottawa Project Management Team sent proposals to Members of the Provincial
Parliament in support of the “Making 211 Accessible to all Residents of
Ontario” proposal. This proposal was
part of a collective call to action, whereby United Way organizations across
the province asked the Government of Ontario to support and partner in a
province-wide 211 system. With funding
from the 2006-2007 budget, the Government of Ontario’s Ministry of Community
and Social Services answered this call, ear-marking $1.4 million for the call
centre start-up activities required to launch the 211 service.
The Government of
Ontario placed restrictions on the use of this start-up funding. First, it cannot be used to fund 211
operations. Second, communities must
demonstrate that they have secured adequate funding from other sources to
operate the 211 service for a minimum of one year.
This new funding represents an unprecedented opportunity to kick-start
local 211 initiatives, thereby laying the foundation for a cohesive 211 system
serving citizens across Ontario. Since October 2006,
the Ontario 211 project team has been working with 211 teams in Ottawa, Thunder
Bay, Halton Region and Windsor to build capacity for their telephone
service. These communities will join
the existing 211 operations in Collingwood, Niagara Region and Toronto to form
the backbone of a province-wide 211 system, providing service to 50 percent of
Ontario residents.
In addition, the
Ministry of Finance provided a $3 million grant over three years from the
Strengthening our Partnerships program, to expand and enrich 211 delivery over
the Internet. This will include new
money for 211Ontario.ca to extend data collection across Ontario and to further
its work on the development of the human services classification system, or
“taxonomy” in both French and English.
By standardizing references to human and social services and needs, this
taxonomy will enable the Information and Referral Specialists using
211Ontario.ca to better search and find the information they need to help 211
callers.
FindHelp Information
Services, a United Way partner, is leading this province-wide initiative, which
represents the collective vision of more than 40 community-based information
and referral providers in Ontario. 211Ontario.ca will be a fully searchable,
bilingual, Internet-based directory of human services across Ontario. It will
be built on the existing information management and technological
infrastructure of Findhelp Information Services and its partners: Community Information Online Consortium,
InformOntario, United Ways of Ontario, and InformCanada.
In addition to
contributing to these discussions at the provincial level, the 211 Ottawa
Project Management Team has been exploring an alternative model to make the 211
Ottawa service more financially feasible.
The following section outlines the model.
211 Ottawa Initial Operating Model
Governance and Management
The Distress Centre of Ottawa and Region (DCOR) will be the managing
agency for the 211 Ottawa project. As
such, its Board of Directors will be responsible for governance and its
management team will head up start-up activities and ongoing operations. Having
a single organization accountable for this significant project is key to its
success. The DCOR can remain flexible
and responsive to changing community needs and will have the ability to make
decisions quickly.
In addition, the DCOR will seek a contractual relationship with the
Community Information Centre of Ottawa, whose subject matter and database
management expertise is best known through the widely distributed Directory of Ottawa Community Services. The contract will include the provision and
ongoing maintenance of a bilingual database to support the delivery of the 211 call
centre services.
To ensure continued community input, a 211 Advisory Group, comprised of
representatives from United Way/Centraide Ottawa, the City of Ottawa and other
community partners will assist the DCOR.
The Advisory Group will monitor performance and provide guidance on how
to strengthen the provision of 211 services to individuals, families and
professionals in Ottawa.
Start-up Activities
Prior to the launch of 211 Ottawa, the DCOR will oversee:
·
Procuring and deploying the telephony
infrastructure, network servers and computing environment necessary for call
centre operations;
·
Securing call centre office space as well
as the necessary office furniture and equipment;
·
Solidifying relationships with other
community groups in Ottawa as well as with other 211 providers in Ontario;
·
Ensuring that 211 Ottawa meets all
national standards, including the requirements of the 211 Standards Review and
Licensing Panel and the InformCanada/AIRS accreditation
requirements;
·
Designing a public awareness advertising
campaign;
·
Hiring and training the bilingual 211
Information and Referral (I&R) Specialists;
·
Hiring a bilingual 211 Project
Officer/Manager to oversee the set-up and operations of 211 Ottawa .
The DCOR estimates that the capital and start-up activities will cost
just over $225,460 (Please see Appendix A - Funding
Requirements/Start up and Capital Costs Table #1).
Initial Operations
The proposed
service targets for 211 Ottawa include: ·
To answer 85 percent of all calls within 45
seconds; ·
To strive for an average call length of three
minutes; and · A call abandonment rate of less than 10 percent.
The 211 Ottawa Project Management Team
proposes to offer the 211 service seven days a week, from 8:00 a.m. to 6:00
p.m. for the launch year, moving to 24 hours a day, seven days a week in the
second year. The intention to move to
24/7 coverage by the second year of operation exceeds the 211 service
requirements mandated by the CRTC.
Accountable for the quality and management of the 211 Ottawa data, the
DCOR will use its impressive Chaos
Organized call management software, which will:
·
provide the 211 I&R specialists with
structured guidance;
·
enable supervisors to view call reports
and provide online feedback;
·
be integrated with the phone system to
ensure accurate data collection.
In addition to call answer targets, regular quality assurance
activities, including caller surveys, will be conducted. Aggregate data will also be collected on
variables such as the geographic distribution of callers, agency referrals and
the first language of callers. These quality assurance measures will be
coordinated with those of other 211 service providers. This will ensure that 211 Ottawa evaluation
reports are consistent with the standard evaluation reports commonly used by
all 211 service providers.
The DCOR will also develop Service Level Agreements (SLAs) with its 211
community partners, including the CIC. As managing agency, the DCOR is further
responsible for guaranteeing that the Information and Referral Specialists as
well as the Database Specialists achieve the designated professional
certification standards, administered by InformCanada/AIRS.
Ongoing Community Consultations
Throughout these initial stages, individual consultations with community
stakeholders will be ongoing to ensure that they are involved in the
development of the 211 Ottawa service. During the second quarter of 2007, more
formal briefing meetings with community groups will take place to apprise them of
the upcoming activities. Regular
project updates to stakeholders will also be an integral part of the 211 Ottawa
communications strategy.
Launch Year Operational Budget
Based on the experience of other communities, it is estimated that
72,000 calls will be made to 211 Ottawa during its first year of
operations. To meet this call volume,
the DCOR will hire a 211 Manager, as well as 4.8 full-time equivalent (FTE)
I&R specialists to begin work on October 1, 2007 and an additional 2 FTEs
to commence in January 2008 if warranted by call volumes. It is anticipated
that the database will be provided by the Community Information Centre.
The following is a brief breakdown of the estimated costs for the pilot
year operations. For complete budget details, please see Appendix A - Funding Requirements/Year 1 Operating Costs
Table #2.
Budget Item |
Estimated Cost |
Salaries, training and professional
development |
$ 364,000 |
Telephony, IT, rent and management |
$ 164,335 |
French translation, multilingual
interpretation and promotion |
$
42,400 |
Total |
$ 570,735 |
Project Milestones
The 211 Ottawa Project Management Team is confident that funding for 211
Ottawa’s launch year can be obtained.
Much of the planning, preparation and consultations for the project are
advanced as well. Consequently, the
project team and the DCOR can move
quickly and decisively to introduce 211 to Ottawa before the end of 2007.
Overall, the plan for 211 Ottawa is to execute a soft launch of the
service by the beginning of the fourth quarter of 2007. Then, following a short period of
fine-tuning, the Ottawa 211 service would be formally launched to the Ottawa
community in early February of 2008. By
this time, it is further anticipated that longer-term funding and plans for
expanding the service on a regional basis would be established.
The chart on the following page
outlines the major project milestones.
211 Ottawa Launch
Milestones |
Q1-07 |
Q2-07 |
Q3-07 |
Q4-07 |
Q1-08 |
Pilot Year Funding Secured |
× |
|
|
|
|
211 Manager Hired |
|
× |
|
|
|
211 office secured and set-up for
operations |
|
× |
|
|
|
I&R Specialists recruited and hired |
|
× |
|
|
|
Testing of 211 telephony and related
systems |
|
× |
|
|
|
Communication strategy developed; Application made for 211 license and
rights to use logos and graphics |
|
× |
|
|
|
Social service organizations briefed |
|
× |
|
|
|
MOUs reached with 311, 911 and other
agencies |
|
× |
|
|
|
211 Ottawa Advisory Committee
established |
|
× |
|
|
|
Agreement reached between DCOR and CIC
on database management |
|
× |
|
|
|
Municipal approval obtained to meet CRTC requirements and to move
ahead with 211 accreditation. |
× |
|
|
|
|
Communications strategy completed |
|
|
× |
|
|
Training of I&R Specialists
completed |
|
|
× |
|
|
Plan for 24/7 service developed |
|
|
× |
|
|
Plan for Public Launch completed |
|
|
× |
|
|
Public communications campaign launched |
|
|
× |
|
|
211 Ottawa Soft Launch |
|
|
|
× |
|
211 Ontario.ca goes online |
|
|
|
× |
|
Reports/evaluation criteria for pilot
year operations developed |
|
|
|
× |
|
AIRS Accreditation application completed |
|
|
|
× |
|
Proposals for funding renewals completed |
|
|
|
× |
|
Plan for 613 regional service completed |
|
|
|
× |
|
Agreements reached with other
municipalities and United Ways on 211 region-wide service |
|
|
|
|
× |
211 Ottawa service offered on a 24/7
basis |
|
|
|
|
× |
211 Ottawa Hard Launch – Feb 2008 |
|
|
|
|
× |
“The mission of 211 Canada is to effectively connect
people with the appropriate information and services, enhance Canada’s social
infrastructure and enable people to fully engage in their communities.”
211 Canada
Steering Committee
|
The 211 Ottawa project is now at a crucial crossroads. With provincial
funding earmarked for making 211 accessible across Ontario, the project has
gained new momentum. But this window of
opportunity will not be open for long. To obtain
start-up funding, the 211 Ottawa Project Management Team must secure the
funding necessary for 211 Ottawa’s launch year operations before March 31,
2007.
Early
in the first quarter of 2007, the 211 Ottawa Project Management Team will make presentations to United Way/Centraide Ottawa, and to
the City of Ottawa. At this time, the
team will also approach other potential funding organizations, including the
Federal Government (Service Canada, Citizenship and Immigration Canada),
foundations and corporations. And throughout this process, meetings with
human and social service organizations throughout the Ottawa community will
continue.
Work with the 211Ontario.ca project team is also ongoing. In November, 211 Ottawa collaborated with
FindHelp Information Services for the 211Ontario.ca consultations. These consultations garnered additional
support for the 211Ontario.ca project from stakeholders, including Francophone
and Aboriginal groups. This vital
collaboration will continue well into the future as the 211Ontario.ca project
takes shape over the coming two years.
From its inception five years ago, the 211 Ottawa project has been a
story of partnerships, collaboration and consultation:
·
The City of Ottawa and United
Way/Centraide Ottawa have worked
closely together, committing both funding and the energy and expertise of their
staff to make 211 Ottawa a reality;
·
The 211 Ottawa Project Management
Team has forged robust relationships with 211 service providers across the
province, with 211Ontario.ca and with the 211 Canada Steering Committee;
·
Through its extensive consultations,
the team has gained the keen support of community groups and human and social
services agencies across the city.
They appreciate the tremendous potential of 211 Ottawa in helping them
to better meet the needs of the people of Ottawa;
·
Currently 211 Ottawa is exploring a
partnership with Leadership Ottawa to provide assistance in development of a
Communications and Marking plan.
Financial projections for start up and capital costs
are based on setting up the 211 Ottawa service between April and October.
Table
#1
Ottawa 211 Budget Estimates Start-Up and Capital Costs |
2007 |
See Notes |
Call Centre Capital Costs |
|
|
Telephony
infrastructure (phones, headsets, licences, fibre network, T-1 line card, NBX
upgrade, switch) |
31,225 |
1 |
Network
server (UPS, server, wiring, racks)
|
40,830 |
2 |
Computers,
monitors, software |
15,505 |
3 |
Workstations/chairs |
15,000 |
4 |
Office
refurbishing |
20,000 |
5 |
Call
tracking software |
10,000 |
6 |
AIRS
accreditation application / 211 licensing fee |
17,000 |
7 |
Advertising
campaign (design and implementation) |
27,000 |
8 |
Hiring
and training of 211 I&R Specialists |
6,000 |
9 |
211
Project Launch Coordinator |
42,900 |
10 |
|
|
|
Grand Total of Capital Costs |
$225,460 |
|
Notes on Budget Estimates:
Note
1 - Telephony Infrastructure
DCOR's current ACD
telephone system is able to handle the demands of a 211 system subject to
additional phones and headsets, T-1 line card, agent licences, NBX upgrade and
phone switch. Cost also includes
connection to local fibre network.
Note 2 - Network Servers
DCOR’s terminal servers
will have to be upgraded to “mission critical” servers. Includes network infrastructure, wiring,
racks and installation. With a
comprehensive UPS, 211 will have the capacity to continue to operate in the
event of a power outage. Having two locations further enhances redundancy,
which will be further enhanced when a province wide system is in place. The 211Ontario.ca database could be used by
the I&R Specialists.
Note 3 – Workstation
equipment
Workstations for the
I&R Specialists include a three-panel screen, hardware and software.
Note 4 - Workstations
and Chairs
Workstations for I&R
and Database Specialists include desk, privacy panels and chairs. Manager’s
office includes desk, chair and filing cabinet. Other office furniture includes meeting table and chairs, storage
shelves, and filing cabinets.
Note 5 - Office
Refurbishing
Call centre
configuration should be ergonomically designed to assist in effective
communication among I&R Specialists who draw on specialization and language
skills (other than French and English) and Database Specialists. Without knowing the space, this is a rough
estimate.
Note 6- Call Tracking
Software
A cost of $10,000 is
estimated to adapt DCOR’s CHAOS database for 211’s purposes.
Note 7- AIRS
Accreditation and 211 Licensing Fee
InformCanada/AIRS
accreditation fees are $3,394 plus estimate of
costs and time, including cost of the Review Team visit. Total costs are estimated at $17,000.
Note 8 - Advertising
Campaign
The initial cost
includes design of print, radio and television ads, as well some implementation
costs (air time, poster hording, newspaper ads, etc.).
Note 9 - Hiring and
Training of 211 I&R Specialists
Advertising costs in
newspapers, Charity Village and Job Bank to hire new staff. Also includes training expenses for new
staff.
Note 10 - 211 Project
Launch Coordinator
211 Project Coordinator
to be hired in May 2007 to coordinate site set-up, systems configuration,
community outreach, staff hiring, etc.
Operating Costs for year
1 are projected with the soft launch of 211 in October 2007 and the formal
launch in February 2008. The service
will be offered for 70 hours/week 8:00am – 6:00pm 7 days a week. The call volume is estimated at 72,000 calls
in year 1.
Table #2
Ottawa 211 Budget Estimates Operating Costs |
See Notes |
Pre-Launch Costs |
|
Oct 1-Dec 31 2007 |
Jan 1- Sept 30 2008 |
Total First Year Operation Costs Oct/07-Sept/08 |
Operating Costs |
11 |
|
|
|
|
|
211 Manager |
12 |
|
|
|
48,263 |
48,263 |
211 I&R Specialists |
13 |
27,616 |
|
55,234 |
191,403 |
246,637 |
Database Coordinator |
14 |
21,938 |
|
12,150 |
40,500 |
52,650 |
Salary contingencies |
15 |
2,075 |
|
4,150 |
9,300 |
13,450 |
Fibre network, T1-line, cellular phones & 1-800 usage |
16 |
14,400 |
|
8,100 |
22,500 |
30,600 |
IT support
|
17 |
2,000 |
|
2,000 |
9,900 |
11,900 |
Training, certification, professional development, outreach |
18 |
|
|
|
3,000 |
3,000 |
French translation costs for resource materials |
19 |
1,500 |
|
|
6,000 |
6,000 |
Interpretation costs for a additional languages |
20 |
|
|
1,600 |
4,800 |
6,400 |
Promotion |
21 |
|
|
|
30,000 |
30,000 |
Rent and facility cost |
22 |
18,666 |
|
9,334 |
31,500 |
40,834 |
Overhead & contingency |
23 |
8,820 |
|
9,257 |
19,858 |
29,115 |
Sub-total |
|
$97,015 |
|
$101,825 |
$417,024 |
$518,849 |
Management fee |
24 |
31,366 |
|
10,183 |
41,702 |
51,885 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Grand
Total of Operating Costs |
|
$128,381 |
|
$112,008 |
$458,726 |
$570,735 |
Notes on Budget Estimates:
Note 11 - Staffing for
Operations
·
Salaries include benefits.
·
Overall staffing levels reflect the call volume
estimates and the ensuing FTE requirements. The call volume is estimated at
72,000 calls per year.
·
Salaries will increase by an average of 2.5% per year
(this includes some allowances for step increases for new staff).
·
The 211 Manager, I&R Specialists and Database
Coordinator salaries are within the salary ranges of comparable non profit
positions and in line with current DCOR structure. These salaries are below municipal salaries for similar
positions. This remains a consideration
when hiring from the smaller bilingual labour pool.
·
The benefit costs are at the current DCOR level of
17%.
·
Staff coverage for 10/7 has been calculated.
Note 12 - 211 Manager
Assumes a full-time position
in 2008 at a salary of $55,000 + benefits of 17% ($9,350) for a total of
$64,350.
Note 13 - 211 I&R
Specialists
Assumes 4.8 FTE’s
bilingual I&R Specialists are hired in 2007 and an additional 2 FTE’s hired
in 2008 for a total of 6.8 FTE’s.
Salaries are calculated on the need to cover 3,650 hours per year (70
hours per week), with a minimum of three full-time I&R Specialists covering
at all times. During the peak period
between 9:00 a.m. and 3:00 p.m., one additional part-time I&R Specialist
would be required. Salary is set at
$17.00 per hour, based on a 35-hour work week for full-time staff (6 FTE’s),
and a 30-hour work week for part-time staff (.8 FTE’s) = $212,670 + 17%
benefits ($36,154) for $248,824.
Note 14 - Database
Coordinator
The bilingual database
coordinator is key to database management.
Full-time salary in 2008 is estimated at $45,000 + 17% benefits ($7,650)
for a total of $52,650.
Note 15 - Salary
contingencies
Salary contingencies and
recruitment costs including on-call supplements, overtime, statutory holiday
pay, staff hiring, parking, etc.
Note 16 - Fibre Network,
T1-line, Cellular Phones & 1-800 Usage
Monthly costs for fibre
network, T-1 line, cellular phones, and 1-800 number. Note: It appears that all of Ottawa would be in the local calling
area of the 211 phone centre if it is located in the Ottawa-Gatineau exchange
area. However, when Ottawa 211 serves
eastern Ontario, a toll free number will be needed for long distance incoming calls
(which are at no charge to callers within the area served by 211). With fibre optics, there is no charge for
high speed internet.
Note 17 - Technical
Support
Information technology
support is outsourced by DCOR.
Note 18 - Training,
Certification, Professional Development, Outreach
Costs related to ongoing
training, certification renewals, professional development and community
outreach.
Note 19 - Translation
Public reports on 211
would have to be produced in both languages.
Using the evaluation plan developed for the provincial 211 roll out, the
template could be translated, statistics entered each month and the narrative
would be the additional cost each quarter. Annual reports and press releases
would incur additional translation costs.
Note 20 - Interpretation
Contract with Tele-Interpreters
using a three-way conference call between the I&R Specialist, a
non-English-speaker and an interpreter speaking one of over 150 languages.
Tele-Interpreters have an agreement for AIRS members and serve hundreds of 211
centres in the US. There is no fee to sign up. Services are invoiced monthly for any calls that
utilize interpreters. I&R Specialist call a toll-free 800 number, and
interpreter is accessed immediately.
Cost is US$1.54/minute. Estimate
2% of calls require interpretation and they average 7-8 minutes in
duration. Based on 1,300 calls per
year.
Local and Canadian
Interpretation services will also be explored.
Note 21 - Advertising
Campaign (Implementation)
Costs associated with
public launch in February 2008 and ongoing media coverage.
Note 22 - Facility
Rental
New office space is
required to allow for expansion to accommodate the call centre and an eventual
9 staff (of whom maybe no more than 6 would generally be there at the same
time) and to avoid any expensive “mid-project move”. The office space is estimated as a 5-year lease for 1,500 sq. ft.
at an initial $28.00/square foot.
Note 23 - Administrative
Overhead/Contingency
Administrative
overhead/contingency is estimated at 10% of total costs in 2007 ($146,675 x 10%
= $14,668), and 5% of total costs in 2008 and beyond. Includes costs related to memberships, subscriptions, audit and
other professional fees, liability insurance, photocopier, office supplies,
bank charges, postage and courier charges, etc.
Note 24 - Management Fee
DCOR’s management fee is
set at 10% of total costs. For 2007,
this fee is applied to both the start-up/capital and operating budgets
($386,803 X 10% = $38,680).
Risk |
Risk Mitigation |
Sustainable Funding |
|
· Sustainable
funding is not obtained for funding
beyond the first year |
·
Provincial support for start up and capital costs provides
a unique opportunity to get 211 operational ·
It is easier to obtain resources for a service that exists
and is responding to information requests from citizens ·
Future partnerships with 311, CCAC and other information
providers can continue to be explored during the first year of operation |
· Province
does not continue to invest in 211 |
·
Solid business plan to come forward from Ontario 211 ·
211 centres demonstrate efficiencies and effectiveness of
211 for citizens of Ontario ·
Potential public, agency and stakeholder backlash if
funding stops ·
Meetings with Premier and MPP’s to discuss value of 211 to
the province ·
Other provinces (BC and NS) show leadership in supporting
211 in their provinces |
· 211 Service
closes after 1 year of service |
·
72,000 individuals will have received information ·
Database will have been increased and developed to be part
of the 211Ontario.ca database ·
Solid partnerships have been developed to continue to
pursue funding options ·
Those who have directly benefited from the service in year
1 support new efforts to secure funding |
· City of
Ottawa cannot provide financial support in 2007 |
·
Approval of 211 to operate in the municipality and the 211
service provider is what is required ·
Request City to look at staff secondment and in kind
services ·
Re-examine partnership with 311 ·
Demonstrate value of services and prepare for 2008 budget
process |
· United Way
cannot provide all the required support |
·
Support DCOR in securing additional financial resources ·
Consider “in kind” services |
Governance and
Community Support |
|
·
The 211 community-based service is not understood or
supported by community agencies and politicians. |
·
Establish an effective communication strategy to build and
maintain sound relationships including a 211 Community Advisory Committee |
·
Unclear relationships with agencies that provide crises
lines, 911, emergency preparedness etc |
·
Build on service protocols established in other 211 211
communities including communication, referrals, cross training and
information sharing. DCOR already has agreements with 911, hospitals, police and 911 |
·
Citizen confusion between 211 and 311. |
·
Coordinate communications to ensure clarity about
differences. For some services (e.g. helping a homeless person), either
number could be appropriate. ·
Develop a specific communications plan for 211 and 311 |
·
Concern about increased service referrals to agencies,
resulting in agencies being unable to handle additional referrals. |
·
Monitor 211 services to ensure agencies receive
appropriate calls. · Service
providers keep the 211 service informed of their ability to serve clients,
including waiting lists. · Quarterly
reports are shared with government and community partners to identify gaps in
services and assist in planning |
Data Management
Provider |
|
· Ensure an
effective working relationship between the Distress Centre and CIC Ottawa. |
· Clarify the
terms of the contract; ensure it provides benefits to both parties and
enables both organizations to feel confident that they can meet their
obligations. |
· Failure to
achieve a satisfactory contract with the Community Information Centre of
Ottawa as the data provider. |
· In the
absence of a contract with CIC Ottawa, an interim contract with an
experienced data partner is advised while the DCOR builds current database of
2678 records and converts to CIOC platform. |
Risk |
Risk Mitigation |
|
Standards and Service
Quality |
|
|
·
Handling increased call volumes while maintaining service
standards as population grows and becomes more aware of 211. |
·
Call volume projections based on experience in other
locations have been used to guide the anticipated demand. ·
Public outreach and education about 211 should be balanced with capacity to
respond to calls. |
|
·
Approval by the 211 Standards Review and Licensing Panel
granted to DCOR. |
·
DCOR will ensure that the Ottawa 211 service meets
national standards and will collaborate with other 211 providers at the
provincial and national levels. Therefore, it should be granted a licence and
be able to use the 211 brand (trademark, logo, name, tagline and graphics). |
|
·
Ensuring that Ottawa residents can access multilingual 211
services. |
·
A subscription with Tele-Interpreters or a similar service
will be in place providing 24/7/365 access to over 150 languages. |
|
Planning for Consolidation with a Provincial 211
System |
|
|
·
Making the right choices about telephone systems and
network servers |
·
Ontario 211 will recommend the telephony architecture for
provincial system by March 2007 |
|
·
Role of Ottawa 211 within a provincial system, serving
eastern Ontario and providing French language service for the province. |
·
Engage neighbouring counties in eastern Ontario in late
2007 ·
Ongoing involvement in 211Ontario activities and the
maintenance of relationships with key data providers in eastern region will
assist in building capacity in this area. |
|
211
for All Ontario, Bringing People and Services Together, Final Report, July 2003
211:
Advancing the Provincial Consolidated System, Final Report, 211 Ontario Phase
2, Tools and Resources, February 2006
211
Know the Facts, United Way of Canada and InformCanada,
October 2006
211
Ontario Q2 Report, April to June 2006
Making
211 Accessible to All Residents of Ontario:
A Proposal to the Province of Ontario to Partner in a Province Wide 211
System, The Ontario Trillium Foundation,
Citizenship and Immigration Canada, United Way/Centraide Ottawa, 2006
Ottawa
211 Business and Implementation Plan Technical Report, Jonquil Eyre Consulting, April 28, 2005
Ottawa
211 Business Case, and Business and Implementation Plan, Jonquil Eyre Consulting, April 28, 2005
United
Way of Canada – Centraide Canada 211 Business Case, Deloitte & Touche LLP, September 2005
1 211 For All Ontario, Bringing People and Services Together, Final Report, July 2003, Available at www.211.ca
2 211: Advancing the Provincial Consolidated System, Final Report, 211 Ontario Phase 2, Tools and Resources, February 2006
3 Ibid
4 Deloitte & Touche LLP, United Way of Canada – Centraide Canada, 211 Business Case, September 15, 2005
5 Ibid
6 211: Advancing the Provincial Consolidated System, Final Report, 211 Ontario Phase 2, Tools and Resources, February 2006
7 Extrapolated from the Deloitte & Touche, 211 Business Case